The evidence is overwhelming: School-time cellphone use hurts children emotionally, socially and educationally. Pennsylvania must ban student use of phones in schools.
Last March, when the Editorial Board first argued for statewide action, only two other states had done so. Only a year and a half later, 27 have.
The momentum within the Commonwealth is also building. Last year, when Rep. Barbara Gleim, R-Cumberland, introduced a bill banning cellphones in school, only eight other members co-sponsored it, all Republicans. This year, a similar bill introduced by Sen. Devlin Robinson, R-Bridgeville, has attracted 18 co-sponsors — that’s nearly 40% of the Senate — more than half of whom are Democrats, including Leader Jay Costa, D-Forest Hills.
The reason for this tidal wave is simple: The proven costs of inaction are rising, and the benefits of enacting cellphone bans are being demonstrated across America.
Children in crisis
Smartphones have been a disaster for young people. The psychologist Jonathan Haidt has collected statistics regarding the well-being of American youth since 2010, around the time smartphone use accelerated. Today, around 95% of American teens have access to a smartphone.
The data he collected run through 2020 or 2021, so they are not attributable to the effects of the COVID pandemic, which likely accelerated all of these disturbing trends.
• From 2010 to 2021, the incidence of major depression increased 161% for teenage boys and 145% for teenage girls. By 2021, nearly 30% of adolescent girls experienced profound depression.
• From 2010 to 2020, the rates of seven kinds of mental illness or other condition increased substantially among U.S. undergraduate students: schizophrenia by 67%, substance abuse disorders by 33%, anorexia by 100%, bipolar disorder by 57%, ADHD by 72%, depression by 106% and anxiety by 134%.
• Between 2010 to 2020, 37% more boys aged 15 to 19, and 48% more girls of the same ages, were admitted to hospitals for acts of non-fatal self-harm. Among younger children, ages 10 to 14, the number of admissions increased 48% for boys and 188% for girls.
• During the same period, suicides among boys aged 15 to 19 increased 35%, while among girls they went up 64%. And for ages 10 to 14, suicides went up 109% for boys and 134% for girls.
These figures represent an unprecedented crisis never before seen in times of economic depression or war or any other social shock.
While causation is hard to prove, it stands to reason that these trends would be related to the emergence of a new technology that serves to distract people from their immediate surroundings; to replace in-person relationships with digital simulacra; to provide constant access to platforms teeming with predatory advertisements and “influencers”; and altogether to short-circuit the process of learning to live in society with others, and to come to understand and grow into one’s place, in the real world.
Growing support
These effects are magnified in the school environment, which is both a place dedicated to learning and, for most young people, the primary place where socialization occurs. Smartphones work against both these purposes.
Last year, we discussed a 2024 Norwegian study that found a 50% drop in reports of bullying, and a 60% drop in mental-health visits among girls in particular, when phones were banned. In 2016, an English study found that student performance “significantly increases … driven by the lowest-achieving students” when phone are banned — and those were much less capable and addictive devices than today’s.
Anecdotal evidence matches the data. When a Catholic school in Scranton banned phones, the school president told WVIA Radio, “You can feel that energy in the building, in even the short time that we’ve been doing this.” A nearby public school superintendent said the same after enacting a similar policy: “It’s a little bit noisier in the building now at different points, but it’s noise of kids conversing, kids getting to know one another.”
This is why public opinion, and the opinion of the people in the room with students, has shifted dramatically on phones in schools. A National Education Association survey revealed that 90% of the teacher union’s members favor banning phones in class, and 83% favor banning them all day. Among all adults, according to Pew, 74% favor classroom bans and 44% support bell-to-bell bans. Both figures increased 6% in the last year.
Saving childhood
Mr. Robinson’s bill, Senate Bill 1014, takes the tougher approach of a full-day ban. This is the right move, and would place Pennsylvania squarely in the mainstream: Among the 27 states with blanket cellphone restrictions, 18 are full-day.
While class-time bans may help with focus during instruction, they don’t help with the problem of short-circuited socialization. They’re also much harder to enforce, with teachers having to monitor use in their own classrooms. A bell-to-bell ban allows for a once-per-day surrender and pick-up procedure.
The strongest argument against cellphone bans is the idea that they would be essential in emergencies, such as during an active shooter situation. While parents would naturally like to be in direct contact with their children, security experts say the proliferation of phones actually makes these incidents more chaotic: It’s far better for there to be more controlled and reliable communication. Schools must be sure to develop efficient emergency communications strategies in advance of any phone bans.
Whatever comfort constant access to their children might provide to parents, the data — and the growing evidence of our own eyes and ears — is clear that the cost of cellphones in schools is far too high. The General Assembly should pass SB1014 quickly, so schools across the Commonwealth can prepare to implement it during the 2026-2027 school year.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.