Pennsylvania’s unprecedented judicial retention battle is, at least in part, a sign of a healthy democracy. However, the well-funded attempt to unseat three state Supreme Court justices, primarily on the basis of party affiliation, only turns judicial elections into just another Republican-versus-Democrat slugfest, without regard for the unique nature of the judicial function of government.

If the framers of the Keystone State’s constitution had wanted judicial elections to result in lifetime appointments, they would have designed the commonwealth’s government that way.

Instead, they incorporated an accountability mechanism: decennial opportunities for voters to choose to recall or retain judges from the county level through the statewide Commonwealth, Superior and Supreme Courts. This is not merely a way to resolve cases of misconduct — there are other mechanisms to discipline or to remove rogue judges — but referenda that voters can decide on whatever basis they choose.

These elections are meant to enhance the perceived legitimacy of the state’s judicial officers, and they fulfill this purpose best when judges are not retained merely out of habit.

Advertise with us

But running an anti-retention campaign entirely on the basis of partisan grievance, as is happening in Pennsylvania this year, undermines this purpose. Rather, it deepens the impression that the administration of justice, in Pennsylvania and across the country, is necessarily partisan.

Judicial credibility

Pennsylvania is one of 21 states that selects its judges using popular-vote elections, but one of only seven to do so with partisan elections — that is, with candidates identifying with one party or the other. In the Keystone State, we can meaningfully describe the partisan makeup of the courts just like the legislature’s. On the Supreme Court, for instance, sit five Democrats and two Republicans.

Judicial appointments, it’s important to note, no longer avoid this outcome. It is now standard to refer to federal judges, for instance, with the name of the president who appointed him or her to the court. We say that the U.S. Supreme Court consists of six Republican-appointed justices and three Democrat-appointed justices.

Still, the explicit association of Pennsylvania judges with political parties raises particular problems for judicial credibility, especially in an age of increasing polarization and aggressive partisanship. This becomes all the more challenging when so many cases in this battleground state’s courts, from congressional maps to mail balloting rules, have direct implications for elections.

Partisan affiliation should only indicate a judge’s broad approach to legal theory — with Republicans, for instance, taking an approach to constitutional interpretation more in line with the original understanding of the text and Democrats more open to evolving understandings — and not whether he or she will construe the law in a way to benefit his or her own party. Unfortunately, in a political environment where every single action seems to have a partisan element, believing that judges are above partisanship is increasingly difficult.

Advertise with us

Partisanship amok

This year’s retention election offers an unusual opportunity to reshape the Pennsylvania Supreme Court. Three members of the seven-justice court are on the ballot, all of them Democrats: Christine Donohue, Kevin M. Dougherty and David N. Wecht. If any of the three were to lose the retention vote, Gov. Josh Shapiro would appoint a temporary replacement, subject to approval by the GOP-controlled Senate — an incendiary situation for Harrisburg. In 2027, a new election would fill the seat for a 10-year term.

Pennsylvania now joins a growing list of states where judicial elections have taken on national importance, and attracted big money. This is because hot-button issues like abortion rights have been moved to the state level and, most importantly, because states have near-exclusive control over elections.

The state Supreme Court rulings that triggered the anti-retention campaign, for instance, include the approval of legislative district maps and of balloting rules Republicans felt favored Democrats. Most notorious on the right, and controversial to this day among legal scholars, were the 2020 decisions to allow undated mail votes and mail votes that arrived up to three days after Election Day to be counted.

While there is no evidence these ruling affected the final results, they have been linchpins of President Donald Trump’s claims that the 2020 election was stolen from him.

While conservatives have every right to seek to unseat judges they deem unfair, they don’t have the right to make things up about them. Spotlight PA has reported, for instance, that a mailer sent out by Commonwealth Leaders Fund, an organization associated with Philadelphia billionaire Jeff Yass, used an image of a congressional map drawn by Republicans as an example of the absurd districts for which the mailer blamed the Democratic justices.

Advertise with us

It is also deeply unfair, because sitting justices are not permitted to campaign, and therefore are unable to defend themselves.

The voters will decide

Most troubling of all about the anti-retention campaign, however, is how it makes no distinctions among the three justices it’s targeting. The idea is that the three Democrats rule in lockstep. That’s simply not true.

In fact, all three have dissented, each on different occasions, in cases loathed by conservatives. This is because Justices Donahue, Dougherty and Wecht, each have distinctive judicial styles and principles.

Lumping them together into a simplistic “Vote No” campaign unmasks the anti-retention effort as interested in partisanship first, and the law second (or not at all). It’s guilty of exactly what it’s accusing the three Democrats of. And therefore it promises to promote not independent jurists, but partisan Republicans to replace them.

Pennsylvanians need to trust that the judicial branch is as free as possible from partisanship, not that all justice is necessarily partisan. Voters can decide for themselves whether retaining Justices Donahue, Dougherty and Wecht would help that cause. But the baldly partisan anti-retention campaign certainly is not helping.

Editor’s note: A version of this editorial with duplicate paragraphs was originally posted. We apologize for the error.