The deal struck by Allegheny County Executive Sara Innamorato to keep Pittsburgh Regional Transit bus stops within the Waterfront shopping complex may seem insignificant — especially after PRT just escaped, at least for now, massive service cutbacks due to a lapse in state funding. But this episode offers two important lessons in the importance of transit for mobility, and for the regional economy.

First, the reaction to the bus stop closures and their restoration demonstrates the benefits of public transit to private interests. Second, it highlights the need to enforce standards of conduct to keep public services truly public.

In late September, PRT announced that it had been unable to reach a deal with the Waterfront’s owners, M&J Wilko Ltd., to keep bus stops on the sidewalk immediately in front of the Giant Eagle and Target. PRT would continue the stops along public streets — Amity St. and Waterfront Dr. — but the owners would no longer permit PRT to access the private roads adjacent to the major retailers.

Waterfront management argued that the stops represented a safety concern, emphasizing the traffic caused by the frequent buses. But a statement attributed to the complex’s general manager — which began, “In an effort to maintain a family-friendly atmosphere” — hinted at other concerns: rude or disruptive behavior around the bus stops, particularly by young people.

Advertise with us

This gets at a chronic challenge for public transit, which is the public perception that it causes more trouble than it’s worth. The result, however, should demonstrate the opposite: that transit serves people and benefits them and the community in ways that can’t be replicated. But it takes strong leadership to ensure it continues to work effectively.

In the case of the Waterfront, the bus stops in question are among the most important (non-Downtown) nodes in the entire system. Six routes serve the complex, and about 400 riders a day use the Target and Giant Eagle stops. They particularly serve older and disabled riders who value their proximity to groceries and other necessities. The replacement stops would have been about 1,000 feet from the stores, making carrying goods to the bus much more difficult, if not impossible, for many riders.

At the same time, we sympathize with shoppers — surely including the older and disabled bus riders — who are troubled by poor behavior around the stops. Public places and services can only remain available to all if those who use them maintain basic standards of conduct, and those who run them enforce those standards.

While the details of the deal struck by Ms. Innamorato have not been released, providing a visible security presence around the bus stops should be an acceptable solution.

The lesson from this episode is that the benefits of transit are typically more than meets the eye, and the drawbacks typically manageable. The retailers at the Waterfront would be worse off if the closest bus stops were removed, because they would lose hundreds of customers each day.

An honest conversation about mitigating disruptive behavior associated with the stops can — and in this case did — allow those benefits to continue to flow. It’s a model of leadership that can and should be applied to public services elsewhere.