Without fanfare, last week Allegheny County Council finally approved five members for the decennial Government Review Commission (GRC), which will produce a report on the workings of the county’s home-rule government in the coming months. The full body will consist of nine people, with the last four appointed by County Executive Sara Innamorato.
The GRC is the very definition of administrative inside-baseball, and will seem to many unimportant in the life of the county. But it is a crucial part of our county government. First, because it has important legal duties and privileges, including proposing amendments to the county charter. And second, because it represents a remarkable opportunity to think big about the very structure of this still-young form of government.
Specifically, as the Editorial Board has previously argued, the GRC should propose a radical reworking of Allegheny County’s assessment system. But it shouldn’t stop there: The panel should also pay special attention to how County Council has developed in the 25 years of home rule, and consider significant changes to the legislature’s structure.
But this will only matter if the government itself takes it seriously. The Innamorato administration should follow through on a GRC recommendation from the 2015 study, and hold public hearings on the GRC study.
Growing pains
The Government Review Commission reflects the humility of the framers of Allegheny County’s government. The men and women, led by the late Jim Roddey, who drafted the county charter in the late 1990s recognized something very important: No matter their best efforts, the actual working-out of the government they designed would not be exactly what they expected, and would expose flaws they couldn’t anticipate.
Therefore, they included in the charter a regular study of the home-rule government by an independent commission, beginning in 2005 and recurring every ten years thereafter. Besides offering Allegheny County a decennial opportunity to take stock of its form of government, the GRC has the additional benefit of insulating elected officials from the study process. This allows the commission to operate with minimal concern for politics, and therefore to propose controversial reforms.
The GRC’s remit as defined by the charter is very broad: It “shall study the Charter and County Government, including the organization, practices and responsibilities of all County departments and agencies, and “evaluate the effectiveness, efficiency and equity of the County government and Charter.” It may also recommend action items “to the people of the County” and “recommend amendments to the Charter.”
The 2015 version of the GRC recommended five amendments to the charter, eight amendments to the administrative code (which defines the general functioning of the government) and ten adjustments to county practices that didn’t require changes to the law. Of the 13 recommendations that did require legislative action, zero have been implemented.
Assessment improvements
We suspect the elected leaders’ inaction was due, in part, to the relatively modest nature of the commission’s findings. In order to spur action, and introduce bold new ideas into the public conversation, this decade’s GRC should be more ambitious.
For instance, we reiterate our support for making the county’s real estate assessment and appeals process truly independent, as described in a Post-Gazette op-ed today by long-time assessment practitioner, and current chair of the Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review, Mike Suley. This would be a very fitting topic for the GRC to make recommendations about.
But the commission can go farther. Ultimately, the county’s assessment system will never be stable unless and until countywide reassessments are performed on a regular basis, such as every three or five years. This liberates elected officials from having to order the reassessment, and is the way assessments are done in the vast majority of jurisdictions in the United States. Making the change would be unpopular, because people dislike the very idea of reassessments, but a simple exercise in good government. In other words, it’s exactly the kind of reform the GRC is meant to propose.
Fixing County Council
The GRC should also closely study the structure of County Council. A decade ago, the previous GRC recommended that councilmembers’ pay should be adjusted from a “per-meeting stipend” to a “salary” equal to 10% of the county executive’s. This went unheeded.
In the decade since, the awkwardness of Allegheny County Council has only grown more pronounced. It was clearly designed as a very weak, part-time legislature, with the lion’s share of authority vested in the county executive and his or her appointed county manager. Yet, over time, councilmembers have begun to realize that some of its powers, such as approving appointments and contracts and, most of all, signing off on the budget, give it significant leverage over the executive branch.
Council’s testing of its limits has resulted in tense relationships between the overwhelmingly Democratic body and two consecutive Democratic county executives, with very different ideological and management profiles. We increasingly think the problem is in the structure of Council itself.
Specifically, over time the amount of work councilmembers have performed, from vetting executive branch budgets and legislation to constituent services, has increased considerably. As Council has asserted itself in more and more areas, the business of government has slowed down because many of these nominally part-time elected officials have other professional responsibilities, and can be difficult to corral for county business. Further, the entire 15-member body shares a tiny staff.
In other words, it has become a part-time job in name only, and at about $11,000 per year, a very low-paying one to boot. Each of the 13 regular member of County Council has nearly 100,000 constituents. That’s about three times as many as Pittsburgh city councilmembers, who have full-time staff and are paid full-time salaries of around $90,000. The GRC should consider whether bringing County Council’s structure closer to City Council’s would result in more responsive and efficient governance.
The decennial Government Review Commission should swing for the fences, and the Innamorato administration should commit to giving its recommendations public hearings, and not burying the report in a file cabinet. This is a unique opportunity to introduce big ideas into local governance, and turn them into action.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.