Partisan gridlock hasn’t just held up Pennsylvania’s budget for a humiliating and damaging three months: It has also kept popular, effective, bipartisan literacy legislation from passing.
This is particularly frustrating because science-of-reading policies have been shown to significantly reduce racial and socioeconomic educational disparities.
While California’s legislature unanimously passed a “science of reading” bill in recent weeks, Pennsylvania’s versions — which would fund training in evidence-backed phonics-based literacy curricula for teachers — have yet to get a vote in either chamber of the General Assembly. This remains the case despite the fact that both the House and Senate versions of the bill have substantial bipartisan support.
The push for consistent curricula and higher standards for elementary school students is based on the experience of the state of Mississippi. Long a state with among the worst educational outcomes in the country, once the Magnolia State introduced (and, crucially, funded) phonics-based curricula and training for teachers, its students’ literacy outcomes leapfrogged almost the entire country.
In the mid-2010s, Mississippi’s fourth-grade reading scores placed it 49th in America. A decade later, it was ninth. And when adjusted for other socioeconomic effects — Mississippi is still the poorest state in the country — it’s number one.
But there’s more: Mississippi’s poorest fourth-graders now have the best reading scores in the nation compared to low-income students in other states. Latino students are also first. And Black students are third. This means that the so-called “Mississippi miracle” didn’t just make a difference in already-successful schools: It had its biggest effects in the communities that needed it most.
In the last week, for the first time in a decade, Mississippi reported some less-than-stellar educational news: On its own metrics, several poorer school districts backslid in the last year. But after such sustained improvement, a wobble isn’t too surprising. And the state’s schools and those districts themselves are still in a far better position than they were a decade ago.
The Magnolia State lesson for Pennsylvania is that structured, phonics-based, high-accountability literacy education is among the very best ways not only to improve reading aptitude generally, but to reduce educational disparities in particular. That’s why it’s so frustrating that Keystone State legislators continue to drag their feet on the budget. Important bills like this that should pass when they get to the floor of the House and Senate can’t get there.
We’re pleased, however, that two Pittsburgh-areas lawmakers are leading the charge: State Rep. Jason Ortitay, R-South Fayette, and Sen. Devlin Robinson, R-Bridgeville, are the lead sponsors of House Bill 684 and Senate Bill 700, respectively. While both are members of the GOP, numerous Democrats from both chambers have co-sponsored the bills, including Senate Minority Leader Jay Costa, D-Forest Hills.
There is one intervention in the Mississippi package that does not appear in the Pennsylvania bill: holding back all third-graders who don’t show reading proficiency. We are increasingly convinced that this is an essential part of Mississippi’s success, because of the urgency it instills in schools, teachers, parents and children. Indeed, a relative lack of urgency, of accountability and of high standards in underachieving schools contributes substantially to racial and socioeconomic educational disparities.
We believe Pittsburgh Public Schools, and other regional school systems where educational disparities along racial and other lines are stark, should implement programs like Mississippi’s. That should include holding back non-literate third-graders, which, though difficult to do, has proven benefits for reducing the disparities. If Mississippi (and now more and more states) can do it, so can Pittsburgh.
We urge state lawmakers to pass science-of-reading curricula and training into law, and all public school administrators to prioritize high standards — especially for the most struggling schools.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.