This editorial is part of an ongoing series entitled Big Ideas for a Better Pittsburgh, in which the Editorial Board collects and proposes new ways for Pittsburghers to think about their city during a time of transition. We invite you to share your own Big Ideas with us at opinion@post-gazette.com.

In recent years, the Three Sisters bridges across the Allegheny River between Downtown and the North Shore have become one of the most identifiable landmarks in Pittsburgh. Whether it’s the attention brought by PNC Park or their usage for festivals, the Sixth (Roberto Clemente), Seventh (Andy Warhol) and Ninth (Rachel Carson) Street Bridges aren’t just local curiosities anymore: They’re Steel City icons.

Yet they can be even more. By closing one of them permanently to vehicular traffic to create a new space for public events, Pittsburgh can create a nationally or even internationally recognized attraction, an example of human-centered design that beautifully integrates the natural and man-made environments.

This is not as easy as placing a few bollards, or Jersey barriers, and calling it a day. It will require creative design to maximize the project’s potential; ongoing work to maintain and program the new, expansive public space; and, above all, tens of millions of dollars to replace state and federal highway funding for the old, beautiful span.

Advertise with us

But we believe the efforts, and the money, would be worth it to create one of America’s, and the world’s, great urban public amenities.

Warhol vs. Clemente

This is an example of a Big Idea that’s hardly new — but one, we think, whose time has finally come. The regular closures of the Clemente Bridge for Pirates games, and recently Picklesburgh and a Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership festival including a fairground Ferris wheel, have demonstrated that traffic is not a serious concern, and that people are happy to flock to the bridges.

Further, the development of Arts Landing, as part of a broader Downtown revitalization plan spearheaded by the Allegheny Conference on Community Development, is strengthening the connection between the Cultural District and the Allegheny River — and, therefore, the Three Sisters.

Meanwhile, on the other side of the Allegheny, the Andy Warhol Museum is creating the Pop District, which is meant to eventually include a variety of arts-based amenities, from public parks to commercial spaces to educational and entrepreneurship centers.

For this reason, with arts districts on either side of the river, we actually think the Warhol Bridge, as opposed to the Clemente, may be the best candidate for permanent closure. This would leave the two on either side generally available for cars.

Advertise with us

But cars aren’t the only vehicles that use these bridges — which raises two serious difficulties.

An expensive project

First, more than a dozen Pittsburgh Regional Transit bus routes use the Warhol Bridge to get to Downtown from the North Side. Its connection with Seventh Street allows buses to stop at the Wood Street T Station on the way to connecting with the East Busway at Penn Station, and closing it would require rerouting along a less efficient path.

Second, and more serious, is the fact that each of the Three Sisters is considered part of the national highway system, and is therefore eligible for state and federal highway funds. While Allegheny County owns and maintains the spans, 85% of the funding comes from Washington, and another 10% from Harrisburg, leaving only 5% for the county to cover.

If the bridge were to be taken off the system, the county would be on the hook for full cost. A recent full rehabilitation of the Clemente, for instance, cost $36.3 million. Similar work is required on each bridge about every 25 to 30 years, in addition to everyday maintenance. Allegheny County can’t justify taking on that cost. This is why there does not appear for a precedent for pedestrianizing a Federal Highway Administration-funded span.

The solution is to set up a separate public-private partnership from which the county could lease the bridge — and transfer the costs. This organization could be funded, probably to the tune of $2-3 million per year, by Pittsburgh corporations and foundations, by Downtown and North Shore stakeholders who would benefit from the attraction, and possibly by taxpayers by way of the Allegheny Regional Asset District.

Advertise with us

The task, then, is to design a people’s bridge that’s worth the cost.

Hometown design

As part of the Allegheny Conference and Cultural District plan for Arts Landing, the renowned New York-based consultants Field Operations actually recommended closing one of the Three Sisters, as a long-term goal. The group drew up preliminary plans.

We’d prefer to highlight a design generated closer to home. Sewickley-based Studio St. Germain, run by architect Nathan St. Germain, has developed a detailed design for a people-only Clemente, which could be easily transferred to the Warhol.

The plan envisions a meandering walkway flanked by trees and teeming gardens, with cutaways strategically placed to provide views of key Downtown and North Shore sites. While some of the design would be fixed — walkways, seating, bike lane — much of it would be flexible and modular, allowing for everything from food trucks to vendors to concerts.

“By converting the bridge into a public space, a major piece of infrastructure shifts its purpose and, more importantly, its recognizability, from a utilitarian one to an experiential one,” Mr. St. Germain told the Post-Gazette.

Advertise with us

We believe that a design along these lines would instantly elevate the Three Sisters from a recognizable symbol of Pittsburgh to one of the most celebrated urban amenities in America, and beyond. It would celebrate Pittsburgh’s legacy — nothing is more Pittsburgh than a beautiful steel bridge — while extending it to the present and the future, by creating a space that people from here and all over want to experience.

It would be a symbol of ingenuity and civic-mindedness that could define the city for generations to come.