The growing divergence between state and federal public health guidelines will damage America’s ability to contain and to fight disease for decades and possibly generations to come. An effective public health regime depends on consistency and authority. Right now and for the foreseeable future, the United States has neither.

A move by a consortium of Western states — California, Oregon and Washington — to develop its own vaccination recommendations, separate and distinct from those of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention under Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert F. Kennedy Jr., is both understandable and discouraging. Understandable, because Mr. Kennedy’s dismissal of the CDC’s vaccine advisory panel represents a sharp break with scientific consensus and mainstream medicine; discouraging, because it likely means the end of unified national public health guidance.

There’s hardly any aspect of federal authority that’s more truly national in scope than public health. Pathogens do not respect state lines. And when guidance varies state-to-state, sometimes wildly, it naturally causes everyday people to wonder if any public health rules are worth taking seriously at all.

For instance, while Pacific Coast states forge ahead with a pro-vaccine alliance, just this week Florida has ended all vaccine mandates for school attendance. While we hope parents will continue to have their children vaccinated regardless, even relatively small gaps in community protection from highly virulent pathogens, like the measles virus, can lead to outbreaks. The end of herd immunity will be particularly dangerous for medically fragile people who cannot tolerate vaccines to begin with.

Advertise with us

At the same time, Pennsylvania has engaged with northeastern states Massachusetts, Maine, Vermont, Connecticut, Rhode Island, New York and New Jersey to discuss their own public health consortium. This follows up on coordination efforts begun during the COVID pandemic — but few would have suspected then that these regional alliances would soon be arrayed against the federal public health apparatus itself.

The United States has a long history of anti-authority sensibilities being applied against public health, but COVID rapidly accelerated the current breakdown of trust in the scientific and medical establishments. While public health officials desperately attempted to maintain and project authority during the emergency, many Americans perceived a lack of consistency that damaged their trust in that authority.

This perceived inconsistency was unavoidable: COVID was a new disease, and evidence-based public health guidance shifted as the evidence accumulated. Yet the demand to “follow the science” as the “science” appeared to change on a week-to-week basis left many people disillusioned, even those who had previously followed medical guidelines without question.

In the wake of the pandemic, among the most urgent tasks for American public health officials has been to strengthen trust among as many Americans as possible. Mr. Kennedy, however, has set out to obliterate it. His moves, particularly on vaccines, have validated the notion that public health is purely political — that is, that medical guidelines are determined by who’s in charge rather than by reference to objective evidence.

This means that states’ attempts to forge their own paths will only be so effective, because they are taking place within an environment where public health is perceived as political first, and scientific second. Further, we expect other states to follow Florida’s lead, especially during the next Democratic administration.

This is dangerous and untenable. Public health is only effective if it is truly public — that is, if there is broadly shared trust in consistent and authoritative guidance. We don’t disagree with every Kennedy initiative, such as the elimination of unnecessary food dyes, but his crusading approach to his job is undermining the very essence of public health. And this, in the long run, will have far worse effects than any marginal gains he makes.