Despite years of efforts, including a task force, mayoral executive orders and a City Council ordinance, there has been no visible progress in enhancing transparency and enforcement in labor contracting in Pittsburgh’s construction industry.
Construction industry insiders report that some of the biggest projects in the city are being built by unregistered subcontractors who bypass employment laws. Because the city isn’t enforcing its own transparency rules, it’s impossible for the public to know who’s actually doing the work, and if they’re legally legitimate.
This long-term problem affects everything from worker safety and construction quality to average wages and tax revenues. But while the problem is complex, the solution is simple: Enforce existing laws that are meant to ensure that public authorities know who, exactly, is building in Pittsburgh.
Shadowy system
There are fundamentally two ways a worker can come to labor on a construction site. First, they can be a member of a building-trades union, such as the Carpenters or the Steamfitters. These unions provide extensive training through apprenticeship programs, as well as continuing education, and then in turn advocate for and enforce standards for safety, wages and benefits.
The value for developers and contractors is a reliable, consistent, well-trained workforce, which they get in return for providing better working conditions and compensation. In the long run, better initial construction means fewer repairs during and after the building process, increasing the value of using union workers.
Second, they can be recruited by so-called “labor brokers.” These people and organizations, often styled as “subcontractors,” collect workers and offer them to general contractors and developers independent of the union system. Often, the “brokers” classify their workers as “independent contractors” with their wages reported via Form 1099 rather than Form W-2 in order to avoid tax withholding and required benefits. This causes a particular problem for the City of Pittsburgh because, even if these workers eventually pay taxes, most do not live in the city and will not remit taxes to the city for work performed here.
Sometimes they’re paid straight cash with no reporting at all. And whatever training they receive is far less structured than a union apprenticeship, while safety standards — which the unions estimate to be 30% of the cost of doing business — are minimal.
Whatever deficits may exist in the union system, the actually-existing alternative is much worse. Because so much of the alternative system flies beneath the radar, it’s difficult to quantify the costs.
But there is no question that safety standards and quality of work suffer, while wages are lower, undercutting the prevailing wage system that unions have fought for and that makes high-quality construction work an appealing career to begin with. The extent of the tax loss from underreporting and misclassification of workers could stretch into the millions in Pittsburgh alone.
Unenforced rules
Pittsburgh officials have been aware of this problem for some time, and have attempted to rein it in. However, those written policies have resulted in little concrete action.
Back in 2017, then-Mayor Bill Peduto signed an executive order that formed the Pittsburgh Construction Industry Task Force. Its purpose included everything from protecting wages and standards to sparking development in underserved neighborhoods, but nothing came of it.
The next year, then-City Councilman Corey O’Connor sponsored legislation to create another panel to report specifically on “construction industry fraud.” This refers to practices that hide wages and deny benefits while skirting tax laws, such as “misclassifying” workers as independent contractors.
This committee first bore fruit in 2021, when Mr. Peduto signed another order, which directed the Department of Permits, Licenses, and Inspections (PLI) to form yet another committee, which would recommend changes to city law that would help it identify bad actors. The order also directed PLI to publish the names of contractors associated with building permits on its tracking website, then called BuildingEye and now called Agency Counter.
Finally, in 2024, City Council passed and Mayor Ed Gainey signed an ordinance that came out of the 2021 committee, expanding the definition of “contractor” within city law to make certain that all subcontractors also had to be registered with the city.
Taken together, these rules should have ensured that the city and the public could know exactly which companies were working on construction projects in Pittsburgh, and that every company doing work was on file with the city, and therefore subject to its regulations.
However, there’s no evidence any of these rules are being enforced.
Simmering crisis
PLI’s permit tracking website, for instance, which maps thousands of building projects, zoning adjustments, code violations and more around the city, still does not list general contractors, let alone subcontractors, associated with projects as Mr. Peduto’s 2021 executive order required. Why it doesn’t do so is not clear.
Further, the continued operation of unregistered labor-brokers at prime construction sites testifies to the fact that the 2024 ordinance, which was supposed to put these people and organizations on the books, is not being enforced. Despite nearly a decade of task forces and new written rules, little if anything has changed in Pittsburgh’s construction industry.
The result is the public’s continuing uncertainty about safety and work quality, and hundreds of construction workers laboring without the protections provided either by a union or the law. A second result is that an already cash-strapped city continues to lose out on tax revenue, because the city doesn’t even know who is being paid what within its borders.
To completely bring this situation under control will require a coordinated effort not just within the city’s bureaucracy, but with state law enforcement. Attorney General Dave Sunday should make rooting out bad actors in the construction industry a priority.
But first, Pittsburgh can simply enforce the rules it has on the books, so both the government and the people it serves know who’s actually building in the city, whether they’re being treated fairly, and whether the public is being properly served.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.