One of the true success stories for Pittsburgh under Ed Gainey’s administration has been the expansion of inexpensive but effective traffic calming measures around the city. These projects, which are sometimes as simple as painting lines on the street in a different configuration, have a demonstrated track record of slowing speeding vehicles, thereby making city streets safer for all — and especially those on foot, bike, scooter and so on.

These projects are also one of the few aspects of city government that are reasonably administratively efficient. The program, administered by the city’s Department of Mobility and Infrastructure (DOMI), is inexpensive to run. It also incorporates resident input: On the city’s website, a user-friendly interactive map allows people to nominate street segments for traffic calming consideration.

The program has attracted the attention of Strong Towns, an organization that advocates for a human-centered approach to urban design. One writer called it “a model for every city”: “The speed at which DOMI acts is helping rebuild trust in neighborhoods that have long urged the city to address the frequency of speeding and crashes.”

Whether Pittsburgh can continue to be that model, however, is in doubt, due to the city’s rapidly weakening financial condition. A broke city can’t be a safer city.

Advertise with us

The prevailing speed on any given road is determined more by design than by speed limits. A flat, straight, wide boulevard with no obstructions will encourage drivers to drive fast, no matter what speed limit the government slaps on signs. A road whose design can be easily navigated at 35 or 45 miles per hour will typically result in drivers going 35 or 45, even if the official limit is 25.

But even small, inexpensive adjustments to the design can result in significantly lower speeds. The most common methods are speed “humps” or wider “tables,” but Pittsburgh drivers are also noticing chicanes — short S-shaped curves imposed by painted lines and pylons on otherwise straight roads — and pylons near intersections that narrow the roadway and force drivers to pay attention.

DOMI tracks changes to average speed, and the percent of speeding drivers, after its interventions, and results are impressive. Average speeds typically decrease by 5 to 10 miles per hour, and speeding sometimes by more than 50%. Average traffic often decreases as well, which suggests some drivers are taking different routes where they can speed, which is something DOMI should monitor closely.

Just this week, the Gainey administration announced traffic calming measures for Larimer Avenue in Larimer, where recent development, such as Cornerstone Village and Steel City Squash, have increased foot traffic along and across a road that can easily be driven at high speed. Other projects in the works, according to the DOMI online map, include Imogene Road in Glen Hazel, a long stretch of Stanton Avenue from the Sunnyside School to the Dilworth School, and Pioneer Avenue in Brookline from the Dormont line to Brookline Boulevard.

There is some doubt, however, that the pace of DOMI’s work can continue. The looming financial crisis for the city may mean a lot less money will be available for traffic calming: These measures may be inexpensive, but they aren’t free.

Advertise with us

For instance, the Gainey administration’s 2025 budget projects that the amount the city will be able to spend of its own money for street improvements will drop from about $1 million this year to $400,000 next year. Even well-managed programs like DOMI’s traffic calming ultimately depend on sound fiscal management.

We hope, however, that given its proven success, the next mayoral administration will further prioritize and strengthen the city’s traffic calming program.