A deceptive attempt by the Gainey administration to scapegoat City Controller Rachael Heisler for a recent lapse in refuse collection has thrown further light on Pittsburgh’s struggles to maintain its vehicle fleet, along with a wasteful maintenance contract that’s costing taxpayers extra money for unaccountable services.

Contrary to claims from administration officials, an ongoing dispute among the administration, the Controller and Transdev Fleet Services (TFS), the company with which the city contracts for its vehicle maintenance, had nothing to do with trash piling up on Oakland streets last week. Sources with direct knowledge of city operations confirmed to the Post-Gazette Editorial Board that there has been no stopping or slowing of work at TFS operations. The blame for the lapse rests solely with the overall management of the city’s aging, expensive-to-maintain vehicle fleet.

This is a structural problem that predates the Gainey administration, which has purchased several new garbage trucks in recent years. This makes it especially bizarre that the Mayor’s Office would choose to blame Ms. Heisler, when the trash incident was relatively minor and easily explainable as the kind of slip-up that comes with running a big city with old garbage trucks.

Meanwhile, the administration has consistently stonewalled or slow-walked Ms. Heisler’s requests for supporting documentation from TFS, and her office’s request for an official legal analysis of the contract in question. In fact, the administration has made threats of work stoppages on TFS’ behalf, which there is no evidence the company has ever made directly. Which raises the question: Why is the Gainey administration so aggressively defending the interests of its vendor against Pittsburgh taxpayers?

Advertise with us

Free money

Like all matters of city governance, this is a complicated controversy with deep roots. For several years over two separate Controllers, Michael Lamb and Ms. Heisler, the city’s fiscal watchdog has raised concerns about the expensive fleet maintenance deal with TFS (until recently called First Vehicle). In 2023, when City Council was considering extending the contract for an unprecedented 10 years for a whopping $136 million, Mr. Lamb wrote to Council to express his concerns, including that the financial terms were unfavorable to the city while documentation from the vendor was spotty.

Council eventually re-upped for six years instead of 10, but the concerns about the contract remained.

The key issue involves the way the city pays for so-called “target” and “non-target” services. Target services are, essentially, routine maintenance, while non-target services arise from collisions or other unpredictable events. For target services, the city traditionally pays TFS a monthly lump sum, regardless of the amount of work done, equal to one-twelfth of the annual contract, while TFS only provides the city with documentation of the work done on an annual basis. For non-target services, the city pays a variable amount based on actual services rendered.

Then, at the end of the year, TFS refunds the city for overpayment for target services. But not in full: at 80 cents on the dollar. In 2023, the overpayment was about $875,000 — an amount the city essentially gave to TFS as an interest-free loan — while the company pocketed about $175,000 of taxpayer dollars.

Awaiting advice

The issue escalated this spring when Ms. Heisler indicated that she was asserting her right under city law not to pay TFS target services invoices without true supporting documentation — that is, an actual accounting of work done during the month. TFS holds that it is owed the full monthly lump sum, but Ms. Heisler points to this contract language: “All costs invoiced for Target Services, except for fee, will be actual net costs as paid by the Contractor.” (emphasis added)

Advertise with us

She argued that her office was owed an accounting of those costs, and that the city only owes those costs, thereby avoiding overpayment.

The Controller’s Office first received invoices for 2025 from the Office of Management and Budget in April, and in early May the Controller appealed to the city’s Law Department for an opinion about the contract’s ambiguity. If the solicitor determined that the city owed the full lump sum, Ms. Heisler indicated she would put aside her reservations and pay it.

As of this writing three months later, the Law Department has not rendered an opinion to the Controller. Meanwhile, OMB Director Jake Pawlak has asserted in a public letter that his office “agrees with TFS’ position” that the city owes the full one-twelfth payment each month. But OMB has not furnished the legal basis for that opinion to the Controller.

Taking sides

In July, Ms. Heisler released partial payment to TFS of newly documented “actual net costs,” but not the full lump sum. The difference was about $400,000. TFS, meanwhile, is withholding last year’s reimbursement — that is, the city’s overpayment of taxpayer dollars — to the tune of nearly $700,000.

The Gainey administration is claiming that the reimbursement is essential for paying for ongoing non-target services, resulting in delays leading to lapses in trash pickups. Sources with knowledge of fleet operations deny this is the case. In any event: If the city can’t front a few thousand dollars for essential repairs during a legal dispute, its financial situation must be far worse than the administration has let on.

Advertise with us

The bigger question, to which there are at this stage no clear answers, is why the Gainey administration is so aggressively defending TFS’ interests, to the extent of threatening Pittsburghers with long-term refuse collection delays, while essentially declaring war on Ms. Heisler for doing her job by aggressively defending taxpayers’ interests.

There is no reason for this dispute to have dragged on for several months, which has occurred due to the Gainey administration’s foot-dragging in achieving a resolution.

The administration must release to Ms. Heisler the legal guidance (if it exists) on which it has based its advocacy on TFS’ behalf. For her part, Ms. Heisler must not give in to the tag-team bullying of the Mayor’s Office and a large corporate vendor: She should continue to withhold unsupported payments of taxpayer dollars until she is certain the law requires her to release them.