Nearly every other state is ready for its next fiscal year, but Pennsylvania is, once again, a month late in passing a budget. No state is as late as often and as predictably as the Keystone State, with our state politicians unable or unwilling to meet their constitutional obligation.
As of this writing, 47 states have passed budgets for the 2025-2026 fiscal year. Michigan’s fiscal year doesn’t begin until October, so it isn’t late. The only other state that missed its deadline is North Carolina.
The costs of these delays are largely hidden, from Harrisburg insiders and almost everyone else as well. State courts have ruled that government employees must continue to be paid at the previous year’s rates during budget impasses, which means state functions largely continue. This system, meant to ensure fairness and continuity within state government, removes a major incentive to get deals done — partly by muting public ire.
Meanwhile, organizations and agencies that rely on state funding, such as local governments, libraries and schools, must begin to wonder if their summer funds will be processed as expected.
It is time for structural reform.
No excuses
The annual state budget system simply isn’t working. More than that, the fact that it takes up the lion’s share of legislators’ (and lobbyists’) efforts means that there’s limited time to get other important business done.
Read More
Gov. Josh Shapiro and legislative leaders from each party in each chamber should form a commission to study major reforms to the commonwealth’s budgeting practices — including biennial budgeting, used by 19 other states.
Mr. Shapiro, in the first half of his term, liked to point out that he was the other governor in the country that had to deal with a divided legislature, with Republicans controlling the Senate and Democrats controlling the House. This was a clever way to sidestep criticisms of the administration’s struggles to get s— done, to use the governor’s favorite phrase.
But now he’s no longer alone: Both Michigan and Minnesota have ambitious Democratic governors and divided legislatures. Yet Minnesota has passed an on-time (two-year) budget, while Michigan looks forward to its October deadline.
Further, 11 states have some form of divided government, once the governor is included in the analysis. And all of them (except, again, North Carolina and Michigan) are ready to go for the next fiscal year.
To make matters worse, Pennsylvania has one of the largest, most active, most expensive, most well-staffed legislatures in America. Only Michigan, New York and California are in the same league as the Keystone State, with full-time legislators paid full-time salaries with large full-time staffs.
Compare Pennsylvania to Virginia, a somewhat smaller but fast-growing commonwealth known to be comparatively well-run. In the Old Dominion, the legislative sessions last 60 days during even-numbered years and 30 days during odd-numbered years, and members are paid about $18,000 per year. Here, sessions are year-round (with a summer break typically spoiled by the budget) and legislators make over $100,000 per year.
Time to spare
Virginia is also one of 19 states that passes a budget every other year. These are not just small states: Ohio, Minnesota, Washington, Wisconsin, North Carolina and Texas are among the biennial budgeters.
The main drawback to two-year budgets is a lack of flexibility to respond to economic or political circumstances that might affect revenues or require additional expenditures. Additionally, any errors in budget projections are magnified over 24 months, rather than 12 months.
On the other hand, two-year budgeting gives greater certainty to government departments and recipients of government funds over a longer period of time. And even if there is a political impasse, it necessarily takes up a smaller percentage of the budgeting period, leaving more time to adapt.
After all, it’s hard to imagine Pennsylvania’s budget process working worse than it already does. Take the 2023 debacle, when most of the budget was settled in early August but major implementation language was left undone until December. Only two months later, Mr. Shapiro delivered his budget address for the following year, and the process started all over again.
Legislating should be more than budgeting, but when budgeting takes several months every year, policymaking becomes little more than negotiating one enormous law-and-budget package every summer (or fall, or winter). That leaves dozens of important matters on the table year after year after year.
Big reforms
Changing Pennsylvania’s budgeting system is not simple, since it’s defined in the state’s constitution. It would require an amendment, which is an onerous process requiring passage in both chambers during two consecutive terms, followed by a voters’ referendum.
And since neither party stands to gain from this reform, it’s unlikely either would put the necessary political resources into making it happen.
One way to get the ball rolling, however, would be for a bipartisan group of state leaders to convene a government reform commission, staffed by nonpartisan experts — including at least some not from Pennsylvania, who can provide a fresh perspective not constrained by our way of doing thing.
Biennial budgeting shouldn’t be the only topic on the table: Other big ideas for reform, such as trimming or simplifying the legislature and opening up partisan primaries, should also be considered.
Pennsylvania’s budgeting shenanigans are an annual embarrassment and, for some people and organizations, an annual crisis. It shouldn’t be this way, but simply trying harder hasn’t worked. We shouldn’t need one-party government to get a legal on-time budget.
The commonwealth needs to think bigger about structural reforms to resolve what is clearly a structural problem.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.