A trio of bills reforming Pennsylvania’s juvenile justice system have passed the state House, and deserve full consideration, and ultimately passage, by the Senate. The two principles they articulate — that juvenile offenders should be treated humanely so that detention centers can be places of rehabilitation rather than hardening, and that cost should not be a barrier for counties to provide fulfill this duty — must be placed in state law.
These reforms, sponsored by Rep. Melissa Shusterman, D-Chester, respond to the tension between two realities: detention of juveniles in a secure facility is sometimes necessary for their safety and the public’s safety; and recidivism rates for incarcerated juveniles is distressingly high. Something is not working.
First, House Bill 1573 lays out a revised set of priorities for services provided to, and restrictions placed on, children adjudicated to be delinquent. These principles accentuate the paramount importance of “the unity of the family,” and indicate that the purpose of the state’s interventions should be to preserve that unity, whenever this is consistent with the child and family’s own safety and the safety of the public.
This would correct an institutional bias toward institutional solutions, which tend to overestimate their effectiveness compared to the kind of care that can be provided best in the context of the family home. Further, it would prioritize interventions that strengthen the family as a whole, rather than (for all intents and purposes) declaring the family null and void, and separating the child from his or her parents.
Second, House Bill 1576 expands state reimbursements to counties for various services provided to children who are involved with the justice system — especially legal counsel, which would be reimbursed at 50%. This would complement Gov. Josh Shapiro’s modest (but unprecedented) attempts to enhance indigent defense through state funding to counties that struggle to afford these constitutionally required services.
Third, House Bill 1577 articulates a new emphasis in the juvenile justice system on rehabilitation rather than punishment. The bill lays out strict procedures under which chemical or physical restraints, strip or body cavity searches, and seclusion may be used: never for punishment, and only in the case of “behavior that poses a serious and immediate risk of physical harm to self or others.”
The purpose here is to reduce the extent to which psychologically damaging measures are used in juvenile detention. When these facilities become places where children are further traumatized and hardened, they defeat their own purpose: These young people are very likely to reoffend — one-third in the first year and up to three-quarters within three years. A trip to juvenile detention is often the beginning of a life spent in the revolving door of the justice system, and that’s a failure of the system.
The Senate might take a look at a few details of the bills. While we support funding indigent defense wherever possible, the effect on the state’s fragile budget must be taken into account. And senators should be sure to consult juvenile justice practitioners to ensure that the bill’s language doesn’t imply so many restrictions that their hands are tied when safety is at stake. Sometimes quick and difficult decisions need to be made, and the people responsible for everyone’s safety in juvenile detention mustn’t be paralyzed by vague rules they could accidentally violate.
Despite those caveats, we hope the Republican-led Senate will take up the Shusterman bills. A reformed juvenile justice system can and should be a safer one — for everyone.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.