The Pennsylvania Energy and Innovation Summit hosted today by U.S. Sen. Dave McCormick, and headlined by President Donald Trump, represents a potentially historic inflection point for the Pittsburgh region’s economy, specifically as an opportunity for southwestern Pennsylvania to claim its place in a future shaped by AI.

While we understand the serious misgivings many have about Mr. Trump’s participation in particular, the presence of the president in Pittsburgh has ensured that, for one day, the focus of some of the most innovative sectors in the world economy will be right here. This is a tremendous opportunity for the people of the Pittsburgh region, and the state, and the state (though focused here), worth an estimated $70 billion.

But it will only be a tremendous success if the focus remains on the people — the actual human beings who call this region home (or might someday call it home), who will use the technology facilitated by investments, who will continue to live on this planet in an increasingly unstable equilibrium with the environment.

For this reason, we are troubled by the lack of even token representation at the summit for experts and practitioners in technology ethics and environmental sustainability. These are not optional add-ons to conversations about AI, datacenters, energy and so on: They are, and must remain, integral parts of the discourse, necessary to ensure that whatever gains Pittsburgh, and humankind, make through these advancements are not negated by the costs to the Earth and to ourselves.

Advertise with us

We have heard speculation that investments in the Pittsburgh region at an eye-watering scale may come out of the summit — numbers that would far exceed the figures that were predicted, in some quarters, to result from shale gas extraction and its related industries. The region’s strengths in high-tech education, energy (especially, we hope, nuclear power generation), access to water and, yes, even steel make it a prime candidate to become a national or international node in the developing AI economic ecosystem.

Yet these numbers, no matter how high they might be, will count for very little if they do not improve the lives of actual human beings, and in particular those outside the business and academic sectors who will not benefit ​a​s investors.

More important than impressive dollar amounts, for instance, will be the numbers of jobs created, paying family-sustaining wages. We will be pleased to see boosts to the region’s construction sector, especially for union tradespeople, but we are particularly interested in the number of permanent jobs created in datacenters, energy generation and other facilities. The region also needs economic policies that will ensure the people here will not bear the burden of increased prices of necessities, especially energy.

Equally important will be the environmental protections that will ensure people will not bear the burden of environmental degradation. It would be a mistake to consider investments in computing to be “clean.” The emissions from power generation and the extraordinary amount of water used by datacenters will have serious environmental costs. Minimizing those costs, and striking the right balance between growth and sustainability, will be essential.

Finally, the fruits of AI itself will continue to be mixed, as we have written. Today’s focus on Pittsburgh should also make this city a hub of serious, critical conversations about what AI means, and how it can be deployed to enhance human life, and not harm actual human beings.

Advertise with us

For instance, we would love to see Carnegie Mellon University — which already has a robust institutional focus on technology ethics — and perhaps a consortium of local universities host an international symposium on AI ethics. It won’t be as splashy as today’s summit, but it might, in the long run, be just as important.

Today’s summit is a hopeful sign of big things to come for Pittsburgh. But big doesn’t mean good​ without conscious intention to and specific policies to ensure that it works out well for everyone. ​Focus​ing on humanity, and not financial or technical abstractions, will help ensure our shared future is one worth being excited about.