Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr.’s decisions to end death penalty prosecutions against four defendants in recent months represent important progress toward the end of capital punishment in Pennsylvania. We urge him to end the death penalty prosecutions of the four remaining death penalty cases within his jurisdiction.
The details of Allegheny County’s capital cases are grisly and shoe flagrant disregard for the value and dignity of human life. In the most recent instance where Mr. Zappala has stopped seeking the death penalty, Isaac Smith is alleged to have lured his pregnant girlfriend, Karli Short, outside her McKeesport home with a phone call and shot her in the head. He is charged with killing her and their unborn child.
The three other cases in the county’s death penalty docket are the February 2023 shooting death of McKeesport police office Sean Sluganski, for which Johnathan Morris is charged; the 2015 beatings and killings of Tionna Banks and her grandmother, Valorie Crumpton, in East Hills, allegedly by the father of Ms. Banks’ child, Cesar Mazza; and last year’s bludgeoning of six-week-old Leon Katz in Shadyside, who was in the care of the defendant, family friend Nicole Virzi.
Every one of these cases evokes grief for the victims whose lives were brutally cut short and their families for whom the pain endures, and disgust at the actions of the people who so callously ended their lives. The death penalty may seem morally appropriate, if not necessary.
The argument for not seeking the death penalty in these four cases is not just moral, but practical. In none of them will the drawn-out, expensive and unreliable process of seeking capital punishment bring true justice. They will simply delay, possibly by decades, the final administration of justice.
This is the case because former Gov. Tom Wolf imposed and Gov. Josh Shapiro has extended a moratorium on the death penalty. The last execution in the Commonwealth occurred in 1999. Since the U.S. Supreme Court reinstated the death penalty in 1978, Pennsylvania has convicted 400 people in capital cases, exonerated 10 and executed only three. The cost of these efforts? Over $1 billion.
Meanwhile, over 120 convicted criminals are now awaiting executions, one of the largest backlogs in the nation.
This means that in practice, seeking the death penalty in Pennsylvania is an extremely expensive and extremely time-consuming academic exercise: The likelihood of a convicted capital defendant facing execution is all but zero.
What capital prosecutions do achieve, however, is the lengthy delay of justice. The appeals process triggered by a capital conviction drags on for an average of two decades, putting off both closure for victims’ friends and family, and decisive justice for perpetrators.
The four remaining death penalty cases in Allegheny County would be completed, and justice meted out, far more efficiently if capital punishment were dropped. And there would be no difference in the result, in the event of a conviction: life in prison.
Mr. Zappala has been right to end four capital prosecutions within the last year. This reflects both the reality of the injustice of the death penalty and the reality of criminal justice in Pennsylvania, where the death penalty is effectively abolished. It is not likely ever to be reinstated.
Death penalty prosecutions are expensive and lengthy farces. Ending them in Allegheny County would signal to the rest of the Commonwealth that it’s time, once and for all, to do so statewide.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.