Major land use reforms for the City of Pittsburgh can and should wait for the inauguration of a new mayor next year.
Last week’s City Council public hearing on inclusionary zoning (IZ) lasted about 11 hours less than January’s Planning Commission extravaganza on the same topic. The reason is clear enough: With the defeat of Mayor Ed Gainey in May’s primary election, the issue has lost much of its political resonance, and therefore activist-generated momentum.
This is a positive development for Council and for Pittsburgh, since it should allow much more measured and careful consideration of IZ and other major land use reforms. These decisions, especially in the details, will influence city living and development patterns for decades to come, and must not be rushed.
For this reason, we urge Council to reject both existing IZ proposals — Mr. Gainey’s strict citywide IZ and South Side Councilman Bob Charland’s funded, optional “enhanced” IZ — and to dedicate itself to studying the issue further, including commissioning a study of the city’s housing market. Members should agree to take action only once a new mayor has taken office. This only makes sense, for a city that must get its decision right.
Last Wednesday’s hearing regarded Mr. Charland’s bill, introduced last December. Since he introduced his bill before Mr. Gainey formally introduced his, under Council’s rules the Mayor’s bill must wait its turn to be considered, since the bills would amend the same sections of city code.
Mr. Charland offered an alternative to citywide IZ that mandated affordability in every neighborhood. His bill would incentivize affordability and allow neighborhoods to opt into the program.
We broadly supported his effort, though we noted that some aspects of the bill required refinement, such as the process by which neighborhoods would opt into IZ. We strongly opposed Mr. Gainey’s citywide mandated IZ, which evidence shows would stifle residential development in Pittsburgh, leading to minimal affordable housing production and higher housing costs for all.
But these are extremely complicated policies with extremely far-reaching consequences, and above all we have counseled patience and close study in evaluating the options. There was no good reason, beyond the Mayor’s electoral considerations, to rush the process earlier this year.
Now that the election is over, there’s no good reason to rush the process while Mr. Gainey’s term in office winds to a close. The correct course is for Council to vote down Mr. Charland’s IZ bill in order to clear the way to consider Mr. Gainey’s IZ bill, which Council should then reject.
This has an additional and very significant benefit: As we have observed, due to a quirk of city law, the Mayor’s citywide IZ has “force of law,” which means developers must abide by its rules even though it hasn’t even been introduced in Council. Clearing away that bill also clears the way for more development, right now.
In the meantime, Council should undertake deeper study of IZ and Pittsburgh’s housing market. So much of the conversation around IZ has been based on feelings, speculations and assumptions about how housing works in general and in Pittsburgh in particular, rather than solid information.
It is considered a best practice to undertake a study of local housing market conditions before implementing far-reaching policies like IZ, but most data deployed by IZ supporters here is a decade old. Council should commission a new study that will guide its decision-making.
The primary election was in part a referendum on Mr. Gainey’s sweeping IZ plan. Waiting until his successor take office in January to hammer out final land use reforms, including affordability incentives, not only makes sense, but reflects the will of the voters.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.