The Steel City. The City of Bridges. The City of Champions. Pittsburgh has more nicknames than most cities, and its cultural influence far outstrips its size. It has been a by-word for industry, for strength, for labor, for capitalism and, unfortunately, for shabbiness and decline. It has raised up more than its share of great men and women, from politics to sports to business to the arts.
It is at the intersection of American geographies — Appalachian, Midwest, Great Lakes — and therefore defines a culture of its own, in a way few cities of its size could ever dream to. Because of this, our city can never be anything other than itself. It can change, but it cannot transform — which is both one of its greatest strengths and greatest weaknesses.
It is a place whose gravitational pull is also stronger than its size would suggest. While a generation ago hundreds of thousands of people left its orbit, some escaping but many having to leave, and too many still do so today, those who choose to move here tend to stay. And those who leave maintain ties, and often come back either to visit or for good.
It is a city of neighborhoods defined by the landscape, and therefore a parochial city. But it is also city that, at its best and most confident, strides onto the national and international stage with something definite to offer the world. It is a city that builds things, big things, things that require sacrifice and common effort, things you can tell your children and their children about.
At least it was. Now it’s time to be that city once again.
Embracing builders
With a coming changing of the guard in Pittsburgh’s mayor’s office — an awkward seven months away — now is the time for the city’s and the region’s leadership to generate a fresh vision for Pittsburgh, and for the region it anchors, that leverages its strengths, embraces its distinctiveness and responds to present political and economic conditions. We hope and expect that Democratic nominee Corey O’Connor will take a leading role in this work by convening public- and private-sector leaders and setting a tone of renewed cooperation and pragmatism that will allow ideas to become plans, and plans to become actions.
That vision should have at its core the idea that Pittsburgh is by its nature, and can be once again, a city that builds.
That means, in a particular way, becoming a more hospitable place for people who build, whether they’re building residential high-rises or software businesses, mixed-use developments or small-time consignment shops. The suspicion of private enterprise — that is, of builders — must end. The only future for Pittsburgh, and for the city services that are funded by taxes that depend on economic activity, is as a dynamic city that nurtures entrepreneurship and lures ambitious people and businesses.
During his campaign for county executive, Joe Rockey pledged to pitch 100 businesses on moving to Allegheny County in his first year in office. There’s no reason that should only be a Republican idea. We’d like to see Mr. O’Connor, along with Allegheny County Executive Sara Innamorato, make a similar pledge. The NFL Draft next April could be a great place to kick it off.
Spirit of cooperation
Indeed, we expect that Mr. O’Connor — provided nothing derails his general election bid in this overwhelmingly Democratic city — will be a more reliable partner than his predecessor for Ms. Innamorato, who has demonstrated her own pragmatic streak in her nearly 18 months in office. Next year, with an average age of 40, Mr. O’Connor and Ms. Innamorato will present a stunningly young face of regional leadership, which should manifest in ambitious initiatives that challenge an entrenched culture of inertia.
For instance, with both governments’ budgets under strain, advancements in city-county cooperation should be able to save taxpayer dollars, while making economic development easier. The city and county could also collaborate on seeking non-tax compensation from the region’s major nonprofits for joint initiatives, such as an affordable housing fund that builds or renovates for-sale units.
Any success at renewing a culture of building and of ambition will require under-the-hood reforms to how government works, including serious permitting reform. When permitting offices miss their deadlines, that should be considered a “deemed approval,” rather than a “deemed denial.”
That change alone would radically reshape bureaucratic incentives in favor of efficiency, while removing a tool — intentional delays — used to stymy disfavored applicants. The purpose of government must be understood as serving builders, whether of structures or businesses, not hampering them.
A city that builds
Pittsburgh must be, once again, a city that builds. It’s our legacy. It’s also our only choice, unless we just embrace (poorly) managed decline.
A city that builds will be a different city. It will have to let go of some of its habits, especially those of governance that emphasize bureaucracy over efficiency, and that offer too many vetoes to everyone from politicians to community groups. It will have to empower new people and institutions — young people, like Mr. O’Connor and Ms. Innamorato, but also newcomers who want to make their mark in a city that’s open to being marked by ambitious and interesting people (which might mean sidelining some established interests).
It will have to embrace unpredictability and risk, understanding that while some acts of ambition will have regrettable consequences, habitually stifling ambition has worse effects for the city and region. It will have to tolerate change to the built environment, because the dynamism necessary to compete, and ultimately to grow in population and tax-base, will always require tearing down to build up.
The changes necessary to become a city that builds will not turn Pittsburgh into something it’s not. In its geography, its neighborhoods, and especially its people, it has a core identity that cannot be touched. A Pittsburgh that builds is still Pittsburgh. It will be a better Pittsburgh.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.