An Allegheny County-wide property reassessment is coming, and the sooner the better. This reset will restore fairness and stability to an increasing unstable and inequitable real estate tax system. It also offers an opportunity to reform the legal structures that define the county’s assessment, appeals and taxation system — both so it works better this time, and so it will work better in the future.

County Council has an opportunity at its meeting today to correct one significant problem with that system: the dependence of the Board of Property Assessments Appeals and Review (BPAAR) on the county’s own Office of Property Assessments (OPA). This arrangement, included in the new Allegheny County government created in 2000, gives the executive branch too much leverage to control the appeals process for its own purposes.

The reform proposal, introduced by Councilman Bob Macey, D-West Mifflin, and co-sponsored by Councilmembers Michelle Naccarati-Chapkis, D-Plum, and Dan Grzybek, D-Bethel Park, would firmly establish the principle of BPAAR’s independence in county law. “The Appeals Board,” it reads, “shall have sole authority over and responsibility for the receipt, administration, hearing, and disposition of assessment appeals, consistent with the applicable provisions of this Administrative Code.”

To put this principle into practice, the appeals board would have the power to choose and to manage its own staff, to propose its own budget to the county executive, and to determine its own set of qualifications for membership. At the same time, OPA would lose the power to schedule appeals hearings, which impinges on the appeals board’s independence and gives the executive branch the ability to schedule hearings in a way that delays bad news for the county (and good news for taxpayers), such as tax refunds to property owners.

Advertise with us

These reforms would correct decisions made in the very early days of home rule in Allegheny County, and would reflect the natural maturation of a still-young form of government. In fact, local government professional Paul Leger, who went on to become the City of Pittsburgh’s finance director, foresaw problems with the proposed structure in 2000.

Under the new county government, he wrote in a then-confidential memo, the new Office of Property Assessments “supervises and certifies all assessed values and then acts as the appeals board to hear appeals against the assessments which they have set. These functions could be split. Assessments could be made by a county department under the Executive and the Board would be a true appeals board.”

In the final design, BPAAR — that is, the appeals board that should be independent — got placed under OPA, which itself reports directly to the County Executive. Thus, instead of being a necessary independent check on the appeals process, BPAAR is dependent on OPA for staff, funding and even the timing of its hearings. That was a mistake, and it’s time to correct it.

The existence of the opportunity for meddling with the appeals board is a problem for public trust in a coming assessment-and-appeals process — there are roughly 600,000 parcels of real estate in the county — that will be complicated and vexing to county taxpayers. Anything that can be done, within reason, to enhance public trust in this process should be done. This good-governance proposal, it should be said, does not imply any wrongdoing or threat of wrongdoing by County Executive Sara Innamorato.

The inevitable reassessment isn’t just an opportunity to reset property values in a fair way. By voting for the reform proposal, County Council can also make the county’s assessment and appeals system less vulnerable to politics.