As a contentious municipal primary election season comes to an end, it’s a good time to take stock of the state of democracy in Pittsburgh and its surroundings. The headliner has been a $3 million Democratic mayoral primary, whose cost has been driven in part by outside and dark money supporting both candidates. This funding has come from people and organizations who see Pittsburgh as a place to make a point, or to score a point, rather than as a place that simply needs solid, competent, forward-looking governance.

On the other hand, the existence of a contested primary on the Republican side of the ballot is a hopeful sign. While the winner will be a long shot in the general election, and the city remains a deeply inhospitable environment for Republican politicians, it’s good for Pittsburghers to have visible alternatives.

Yet it would be a mistake to focus all our attention on this the mayoral race. Beyond, there are continuing signs of a robust democracy — especially in the other 129 municipalities that make up Allegheny County, not to mention hundreds more in outlying counties. While we’d like to see even more contested races — incumbency can and does become stagnancy — these hundreds of races for everything from borough councilmembers to tax collectors to prothonotaries (yes, they still exist) will determine more about voters’ everyday lives than federal elections do.

It’s here where we can see the enduring strength of democracy, even against the headwinds of special interests, big money and polarization.

Advertise with us

Not for Pittsburgh

If you only followed the Democratic primary for mayor, you’d come away fearing that all the pathologies of national politics had infected Pittsburgh politics. Mayor Ed Gainey in particular has attempted to make this race a referendum on national issues, specifically the Trump administration, while most Pittsburghers, we suspect, are more invested in what’s happening right here: public safety staffing crises, decrepit city vehicles and equipment, a fiscal disaster that threatens the city’s ability to fulfill its most basic responsibilities.

This is driven by strategy, but also by money. Both Mr. Gainey’s campaign and that of his challenger, Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor, have benefited from over $600,000 in outside spending on their behalf — Mr. Gainey from the SEIU-connected Working Families Party and Mr. O’Connor from the new group Common Sense Change, which was invented for this race, and is funded largely by building trades unions.

Public Source reports that both have received funding from vague non-profit organizations whose own donors are not disclosed. For many of the people and organizations funding both sides in this race, its value has nothing to do with delivering effective services or enhancing economic development for the people of the city. It’s about putting a notch on their belt, or shifting City Hall toward their preferred abstract ideology. It’s not actually about Pittsburgh.

We are particularly troubled by the clear examples of coordination between Mr. Gainey and his supposedly independent supporters: Working Families Party employees staff the incumbent’s campaign, making a mockery of the firewall that’s supposed to exist between the campaign and independent expenditures.

Fresh ideas

Perhaps surprisingly, it’s on the Republican side of the ballot where we see more hopeful signs for Pittsburgh’s democracy. It’s the first time in decades there has been a contested GOP primary for mayor, with two bootstrapped candidacies vying for the nomination. While neither is at all likely to prevail in November, Pittsburgh needs new ideas aired in the public square and challenging the Democratic consensus.

Advertise with us

The race pits former Pittsburgh police officer Tony Moreno against Lawrenceville businessman Thomas West. Mr. Moreno made a bid in 2021 on the Democratic ballot as a moderate-to-conservative option; the votes he attracted likely swung that race to Mr. Gainey. He then switched parties and earned an unusually high 28% in the general election, including winning numerous precincts south of the rivers.

This time, however, we’re particularly interested in Mr. West, whose campaign is based on new ideas that are simply off the table in the Democratic primary. For instance, at a recent debate on KDKA-TV, he suggested cutting the city’s deed transfer tax in order to make it less expensive to buy a home in Pittsburgh. Given the city’s financial situation, he’d have to make up the revenue somewhere else, but that kind of fresh perspective is good for Pittsburgh.

We hope the city doesn’t have to wait several decades more for another contested Republican mayoral primary.

Vote!

In Allegheny County alone this Tuesday, there will be over 1,500 elections — and that doesn’t even include over 5,000 for precinct election officers. While presidential elections bring international attention to the county elections divisions, municipal primaries are, in many respects, a heavier lift.

Unfortunately, the majority of these races are uncontested. This is particularly true for inspectors of elections: There should be a Democratic and Republican inspector for each of the county’s roughly 2,650 precincts, but most of these races have nobody running for them, let alone multiple candidates. We urge civically active residents to run for these important roles.

Advertise with us

There’s no shortage of candidates in the race for Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas, with 22 candidates on the Democratic ballot for eight seats. Most of the relatively few candidates on the Republican ballot are Democrats who have filed with both parties. (The collapse of the GOP in county judicial races is regrettable, for the same reasons of stagnancy as one-party rule anywhere, by either party.)

Here, we urge voters to look for options with robust experience in the judicial system, and to avoid perennial candidates: Judgeships are matters of life and death for defendants and for the public at large, and must be considered more than cushy decade-long (and typically lifetime) sinecures, or bully pulpits for activists.

Above all: Please vote. Low-turnout primaries deliver candidates with limited appeal. The more voices are heard this Tuesday, the more representative the slates will be in November.