More than $2 million is unaccounted for in the City of Pittsburgh’s trust fund for police secondary employment — that is, off-duty work paid by the city and reimbursed by clients — according to sensitive internal reports reviewed by the Post-Gazette Editorial Board. The documents portray a system marked by astonishing incompetence that could easily be exploited to siphon public funds out of the city and into private hands.
In 2013, former police chief Nate Harper was arrested and convicted in federal court for skimming from this same secondary employment system. A dozen years later, despite contracting with a major software firm and undergoing a 2022 audit that identified serious problems with the trust fund’s accounting, that system continues to be plagued by poor administration and fuzzy math, making it ripe for exploitation.
Missing money
The documents obtained by the Editorial Board list 632 invoices issued by the city for police secondary employment, amounting to $2.3 million over the last three years, that appear not to have been paid. Further, the administrators of the Police Secondary Employment Trust Fund, which is shared between the Departments of Finance and Public Safety, do not appear to be making any serious attempt to collect these debts: Of the 632 outstanding invoices between April 2022 and February 2025, more than 70% are more than four months old, and about half are more than one year old.
At first glance, it appears the fund’s administrators are simply incompetent at collecting accounts receivable. This was the conclusion reached in a 2022 audit of the trust fund by then-City Controller Michael Lamb, who found that some clients had overpaid the city while others hadn’t been paying at all. However, “the net […] indicates that a significant amount of money is still owed to the City for secondary employment services.”
Mr. Lamb recommended that the Bureau of Police “should consider the standing of any delinquent secondary employer and determine if any should be revoked and/or reported to the Department of Law.” Further, the bureau should “devise a formal process for the review and collection of balances.” The bureau responded by claiming that such procedures were already in place, but that it would now “memorialize this process.”
Yet nothing has changed. In fact, the situation has gotten far worse. Today there more than 200 clients with outstanding invoices — from the Catholic Diocese of Pittsburgh to Cheerleaders Gentleman’s Club to the city’s own Office of Special Events.
This raises a far more troubling possibility. It is unlikely more than 200 clients have fumbled city invoices for years. It is more likely that many if not most of these invoices have been paid, but the proceeds have not been deposited into the Secondary Employment Trust Fund. Therefore, they are recorded as unpaid, with more than $2 million owed to the trust fund.
If this is the case, then that money isn’t a debt to be collected: It’s simply missing.
Complex system
Police secondary employment is a more complicated matter than it might first appear. Off-duty work can be extremely lucrative, but it must be distributed fairly. During the Harper scandal, for instance, a group of officers known as the “detail mafia” — a “detail” is another word for an off-duty gig — gamed the system to get the best work.
At that time, the city began contracting with the strikingly named Cover Your Assets LLC, which produced software meant to streamline public safety secondary employment. CYA was later purchased by RollKall, which has a near-monopoly on such software systems around the country. RollKall notifies officers about opportunities, such as working security at a business or large event, which they can select from a smartphone app.
Crucially, secondary employers do not pay officers directly: This is to avoid improper financial relationships between these organizations and the officers they hire. Instead, the city pays the officers at the usual overtime rate, and is in turn reimbursed by the client.
But this introduces another problem: Now that the city has fronted the payment for off-duty services, it has to collect those wages from the secondary employer — plus a fee that’s supposed to cover the cost of administering the program.
In order to make this all work, since 2013 the city has maintained the Police Secondary Employment Trust Fund, so these transactions are sequestered from other funds. This makes sure there’s ample resources to pay officers, as well as to cover eventualities like workers compensation or legal fees for issues that arise during detail work.
The suspicion among those aware of the missing secondary employment funds is that they’ve become commingled with the city’s general fund. And that may be the best-case scenario.
Investigation needed
The Pittsburgh Police secondary employment system is rightly notorious after the events that led to Nate Harper’s arrest and conviction. The fact there remain such serious questions about its integrity 12 years later is, itself, a scandal.
But it could be much worse than sloppy accounting or incompetent bill collection. If funds destined for the Secondary Employment Trust Fund have been diverted to the general fund, whether by accident or on purpose, besides being illegal in itself, it could eventually threaten the ability of the trust fund to pay officers, or to handle necessary expenses such as workers compensation.
Even more seriously, the inability to account for this $2.3 million also raises the possibility of exactly the kind of graft that landed the former chief in a federal prison. The truth is that if any of the supposedly outstanding $2.3 million has come into the city, we do not know where it went. The general fund is the best-case scenario.
Whatever the truth is, the 632 outstanding invoices and millions missing from the trust fund demand independent scrutiny from City Controller Rachael Heisler, and possibly from law enforcement. The people of Pittsburgh, and in a particular way the police officers who depend on this trust fund, deserve an explanation — and a government that can be trusted.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.