A deal between U.S. Steel and Nippon Steel continues to be the only hope for keeping the steel industry in Western Pennsylvania, thereby preserving several thousand direct jobs in the industry, as well as in businesses that locate in the region to be near steelmaking activity. The Post-Gazette Editorial Board has joined nearly every economic analyst in the region and the country in supporting Nippon’s bid since it was announced in December 2023.

What has transpired since has been a national embarrassment, as two consecutive presidents have opposed the deal based on the counterproductive advocacy of the United Steelworkers union leadership, and a generalized ill feeling about a foreign takeover of an iconic American firm. But, to repeat arguments we and others have made again and again, there’s no safer international partner than Japan, and Nippon’s proposed investment is the surest way to preserve, and even expand, steelmaking jobs for the foreseeable future.

Many observers hoped and predicted that the November election would mark a turning point for the Nippon bid, once the season of election-induced irrationality passed. This has proven not to be the case.

On the bright said, President Donald Trump has ordered a new review, due late next month, by the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS), which declined to advise for or against the deal in December of last year. Further, the administration has asked for an extension in its response to litigation over the initial CFIUS review, possibly indicating hesitation about killing the deal. Finally, some news reports have indicated that Nippon pledged to increase its proposed investment in U.S. operations from $2.7 billion to $7 billion, though details are sketchy.

Advertise with us

But then, despite all this progress, Mr. Trump has reiterated twice in the last week that he opposes foreign ownership of U.S. Steel. This has once again destabilized the situation between U.S. Steel and Nippon, between the United States and Japan, and between the people of the Mon Valley and the public- and private-sector leaders who continue to use them as pawns.

Enough. It’s time to make a decision and stick with it. There’s no need to wring any further investment commitments out of Nippon. Even if only the original $2.7 billion promise were to materialize, it would be far more than failing U.S. Steel or its only other suitor, Cleveland-Cliffs, could have mustered. Continuing to jerk around Nippon — not to mention the everyday people whom Mr. Trump is supposedly representing — is serving no further purpose.

Tariffs, it should be said, are not a long-term solution for U.S. Steel. They may help the company to limp along, but they won’t free up the kind of capital needed to invest in the Mon Valley, or elsewhere.

The only remaining question appears to be whether the Nippon-U.S. Steel deal is framed as an acquisition of a domestic company by a foreign company, or an “investment” in a domestic company by a foreign company. But how it’s framed doesn’t matter as long as three main conditions are met: Nippon follows through on its investment commitments; Nippon fulfills its pledge to place U.S. executives in charge of its U.S. subsidiary, while making its headquarters in Pittsburgh; and Nippon transfers necessary advanced technology to former U.S. Steel facilities.

We are now in the 16th month of this saga, which has dragged on far too long. Nippon Steel was always the best and only option to preserve steelmaking in Western Pennsylvania, and the counterarguments — whether from the USW or Cleveland-Cliffs or two presidents — have never amounted to anything more than grandstanding. No more. Just let the deal get done.