The second of three storefront locations of the City of Pittsburgh’s street outreach program, which provides access to care and services primarily for unhoused people, abruptly closed this week. Without warning, a sign appeared on the door of the office on Broad Street in East Liberty announcing that it was “permanently closed,” while advising those who depend on the facility to “keep posted” for reopening on Larimer Avenue in Larimer at an unspecified date.

It’s another setback for a program that was slated to receive, but never did receive, $10 million in funding through the American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) — that is, federal pandemic relief funds. Despite reporting from the Post-Gazette Editorial Board that began nearly two years ago, the city has never satisfactorily explained what happened to those funds.

The sudden closure of the East Liberty Reaching Out On The Streets (ROOTS) office is another example of the struggles of the Gainey administration to scale up the program, along with the Office of Community Health and Safety (OCHS), within which ROOTS is housed. Despite extravagant and often baldly false claims about the administration’s successes in responding to homelessness in Pittsburgh, these programs — which represent the city’s primary involvement in what is mostly Allegheny County’s responsibility — have yet to reach their potential.

Smothered seedling

ROOTS storefronts are meant to serve two purposes: a place for unhoused people, or others without anywhere else to go, to access medical and social services, and a staging area for city-employed outreach workers to respond to public safety concerns where their services might be more useful than law enforcement. These are not co-responders, who arrive alongside armed officers; rather, they are called in once it is determined that social services or mental or behavioral health services may be more helpful to a person in crisis.

Advertise with us

In other words, ROOTS has never been about replacing frontline public safety officers. Rather, given the unprecedented extent to which those officers are tasked with responding to people experiencing mental and behavioral health crises, the program gives them a chance to seek non-law-enforcement solutions for people who need them.

It’s an example of a public health-focused approach to violence prevention championed by Mr. Gainey. Unfortunately, ROOTS has floundered on his watch.

The first ROOTS hub was opened in November 2021 beneath Mellon Square Park on Smithfield Street in Downtown, with the Allegheny Health Network as a partner and then-Mayor Bill Peduto in attendance for the ribbon-cutting. At the time, it was meant to be the first of at least six such facilities across the city, one in each police zone. Ultimately, only three ROOTS storefronts opened: Downtown (Zone 2), East Liberty (Zone 5) and North Side (Zone 1).

The flagship Downtown hub closed last year. Only the North Side hub on East Ohio Street remains open, with limited hours.

Where’s the money?

This planned expansion was to be funded by $10 million over two years in ARPA funds, labeled on the city’s federal paperwork as “OCHS-AHN project.” But the contract with AHN was never finalized by the Gainey administration, which resulted in ROOTS becoming an entirely city-run project. And the $10 million was never used to expand the program citywide, even as the homelessness crisis became more acute.

Advertise with us

Moving planned ARPA funds from one project to another is commonplace, though it requires City Council approval. The administration could have decided that ROOTS wasn’t ready to be expanded as quickly as originally proposed, for instance, and reallocated the funds elsewhere.

But that’s not what happened. Instead, on the city’s own ARPA reports, the “OCHS-AHN project” funds were listed as “expended” during 2022 and 2023 — that is, they were never moved elsewhere for other projects, and have been reported as being used for that purpose. Yet there’s no record of those funds being used for the purpose described in the documentation.

This can be seen clearly in the city’s own budget documents. In both the 2022 and 2023 budgets, OCHS was slated to spend an extra $5 million for “Prevention” under the rubric of “Professional & Technical Services” — that is, the AHN collaboration. To be clear, the 2022 budget was written by the Peduto administration, but the 2023 budget was written by the Gainey administration.

But in the 2024 and 2025 budgets, which report actual spending for two years prior, the real amount spent by the department for those services was $4,949 in 2022 and $380,752 in 2023. The budgeted $10 million simply evaporates.

Meanwhile, funding for OCHS as a whole, including ROOTS, has been almost entirely shifted to the Stop the Violence Trust Fund, which was meant to be used for grants to community-based institutions whose work prevents violence at the neighborhood level.

Advertise with us

Missed opportunities

Both OCHS and ROOTS have grown under the Gainey administration, but neither has flourished, nor has either reached its full potential. Funding set aside to make ROOTS a citywide program was diverted, and for the moment it’s down to one independent community hub. The promise of ROOTS has never been fulfilled, despite ample funding to get it off the ground.

Meanwhile, the OCHS co-response program — these are the social workers who arrive at certain calls with police officers or firefighters — is only active from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. Needless to say, mental and behavioral health crises don’t occur on an office-worker’s schedule. Indeed, they’re much more likely to occur during unusual hours.

Despite Mr. Gainey’s claims to have essentially solved homelessness in Pittsburgh, whatever progress has been made is almost entirely due to the efforts of the Allegheny County Department of Human Services, as well as dedicated advocates and on-the-ground practitioners. OCHS and ROOTS, while they are staffed by compassionate outreach and social workers, have not played the role they could and should have.

With more competent and candid city leadership, these programs could have been transformational. Instead, they’ve become more examples of mismanagement.