The opening of a full substance use treatment unit at the Allegheny County Jail is another milestone in the jail’s turnaround, as the facility’s leaders have gone above and beyond the requirements imposed by the federal government in a 2023 consent decree. This unit, offering the full spectrum of medication for opioid use disorder (MOUD), will help ensure humane treatment of inmates struggling with substance abuse. And in so doing, it will make the wider community safer.

The Editorial Board has advocated for methadone to be offered alongside buprenorphine and naltrexone. We have also called for the jail to allow inmates to begin MOUD treatments, rather than limiting access to those with existing prescriptions, as had been the policy. Both these protocols are part of the new ACJ substance use treatment unit.

Across the country, 65% of people in correctional institutions have some form of active substance use disorder. This reflects, among other things, a long-term shift of the burden of care for people with mental and behavioral health conditions onto the criminal justice system.

Jails and prisons are not well-suited to this work. Further, it’s hard to imagine a world in which they could ever replace institutions purpose-built for rehabilitative mental and behavioral health care, including substance use treatment. But the United States — this is a problem that transcends Western Pennsylvania — does not have enough of these institutions, especially to provide care before a person breaks the law.

Advertise with us

Thus, while most people in prison are morally responsible for the crime or crimes they committed, most also have mental and behavioral health comorbidities that, if addressed, could have reduced their likelihood of offending — or could reduce their likelihood of re-offending in the future.

Forcing correctional institutions to provide these services is an imperfect solution — but it’s the simplest immediately available solution. The Biden administration made it a priority to ensure that the nation’s jails and prisons provided a broad range of treatments for substance use disorders, including MOUD. This resulted in the 2023 consent decree, to which ACJ agreed.

Crucially, given both the fragile nature of recovery from substance use disorders (especially opioid use disorder) and the short period many inmates stay in ACJ, the new program also includes referrals to community-based care centers upon release and reentry. Inmates must not lose support for their recovery upon leaving ACJ, and this program recognizes that.

Together with success in lowering the vacancy rate for health care providers at the jail, the comprehensive substance use treatment unit represents the fulfillment of a promise by County Executive Sara Innamorato to prioritize health and safety improvements at ACJ. It also demonstrates the commitment of new Warden Trevor Wingard to full-scale rehabilitation. Mr. Wingard’s work has already received appreciation from the fractious Jail Oversight Board, to which he has seemingly brought peace.

Reform at the jail, not unlike recovery from addiction, is a fragile thing, and will require continuing vigilance — from Ms. Innamorato, Mr. Wingard, the members of the JOB and the general public. But the current trajectory is extremely encouraging.

A more humane jail isn’t just about improving the lives of people inside: It’s about providing for safer communities outside. That means being on the front lines not just of criminal justice, but of mental and behavioral health. ACJ leadership is meeting the challenge.