As Allegheny County stares down the barrel of a full-scale property reassessment, policymakers from the state to the municipal level have considered ways to mitigate tax increases in areas that have seen significant property value appreciation in recent years. One option, to which the Editorial Board has been favorable, is a “longtime owner-occupant of residential properties” tax break, also known as a LOOP.

But all LOOP schemes are not created equal. They must fairly balance the interests of their beneficiaries — incumbent homeowners who should not have their ability to remain in place threatened by neighborhood price increases — and those who will subsidize them: newcomers and renters.

A proposal by Mayor Ed Gainey to institute a LOOP in Pittsburgh, part of his campaign-year “Keep Pittsburgh Home” blitz, fails to maintain the proper balance, shifting the tax burden much too far in favor of incumbent homeowners and against newcomers and renters. The slapdash legislation, whose cost has yet to be estimated but promises to be substantial, would make moving to Pittsburgh (as an owner or a renter) even more cost-prohibitive, while benefitting homeowners whose taxes don’t need to be subsidized.

The principle of the LOOP is sound, and City Council shouldn’t ditch the idea entirely. Instead, councilors should pare back Mr. Gainey’s proposal to include only truly low-income homeowners in the plan, while taking other measures to limit its cost.

Advertise with us

Shifting the burden

Under usual conditions, a countywide reassessment results in about one-third of homeowners seeing tax increases, one-third seeing tax decreases and one-third remaining about the same. But the post-COVID collapse in commercial real estate means that the reassessment will lock in a new sharing of the tax burden, shifted onto residential property.

That’s because anti-windfall provisions in state law will result in a new millage rate based on the overall valuation of taxable property in the county and in each municipality and school district. Millage rates will then be adjusted — mostly downward — so that tax revenues are roughly the same before and after the reassessment.

But if commercial values take up a smaller proportion of the overall value of property in the taxing area — a problem particularly acute for Pittsburgh, given massive write-downs on Golden Triangle skyscrapers and other commercial real estate — that means the post-reassessment millage will be higher than if it had been based on residential values alone. In other words, residential property owners will be paying a share of taxes commercial property owners had previously paid.

Therefore, the coming reassessment poses a particular threat to homeowners with low or fixed incomes who live in areas that have seen even moderate price appreciation since the 2012 base year. Their assessments will go up more than the millage goes down, and they’ll be on the hook for the difference.

Mitigating the problem

A LOOP scheme responds to this by mitigating or eliminating the increase in tax burden for people who have occupied their homes for an extended period of time. That’s a good idea — but it has to be tailored properly.

Advertise with us

Unfortunately, Mr. Gainey’s proposal casts far too broad a net. It would freeze property taxes at or even below pre-reassessment levels for any owner-occupant household that’s lived in place for 10 years and makes up to 120% of the area media income. For an individual, that’s about $85,000. For a family of four, that’s over $120,000.

That’s a compelling campaign-season promise, but the cost will be steep. In fact, no one knows how steep, because the legislation doesn’t include an estimate of how much tax burden the city would be shifting onto homeowners without 10 years in place, as well as landlords, who will naturally pass the tax hike onto their tenants.

A well-designed LOOP is for helping people stay in their homes, such as seniors on fixed incomes who don’t have a mortgage, but whose financial well-being could be gravely threatened by a big tax hike due to housing appreciation in their suddenly trendy neighborhood. It’s not for upper-middle-class households, whose tax breaks will be subsidized by low-income renters. It’s an odd policy for an administration that has made rental affordability one of its primary focuses.

Striking the balance

The Gainey LOOP has another very weird quality: Its determinations are based on assessed value rather than tax burden. Let’s say you own a home in Lawrenceville assessed (a long time ago) at $200,000. If your household meets the longevity and income qualifications, your new assessed value would be capped at $250,000, a 25% increase. But if the overall values in the city increase by more than 25% — a distinct possibility — the new millage will go down by more than 25%. So not only haven’t you seen the big tax hikes your neighbors have: Your taxes have gone down. And everyone else is paying for it.

So here are fixes City Council can and should apply to the LOOP. First, make the calculations based on tax burden, rather than assessed value, which would ensure stable revenues from LOOP properties. Second, decrease the maximum qualifying income from 120% to, at most, 80% of the area median income.

Advertise with us

Third, consider two ways to mitigate the effects of the LOOP on other taxpayers: Either allow the tax burden to tick up a few percent each year, or make some or all of the deferred tax burden payable upon sale of the property, at which time the owner will reap a windfall.

Protecting incumbent homeowners on low or fixed incomes facing a big tax hike is a good policy. But not if it unfairly burdens everyone else, including new Pittsburghers and renters whose incomes are far lower than LOOP beneficiaries.

Campaign-season talking points don’t make good law. City Council must intervene.