Some of the most striking and useful residential buildings in Pittsburgh would be illegal under current zoning and building codes, even though their single-stairway design has stood the test of time, including the test of safety. A new report from the Pew Charitable Trusts shows that one particularly costly regulation — a prohibition on single-stairway apartment buildings over three stories — provides no significant safety benefits, and should be eliminated for buildings from four to six stories.
The hotel- or dorm-like design of most contemporary apartment buildings, called the “double-loaded corridor,” is forced by the multi-stairway requirement in the International Building Code (which, despite its name, is only in force in the United States and several of its territories). The rule was a common-sense response to fire tragedies that took place before modern building standards, but it has had far-reaching consequences that squelch growth and creativity in housing construction.
It’s all but impossible, for instance, to build mid-rise apartment buildings on small or irregular lots — which constitute a large proportion of available space in a mature city like Pittsburgh. Developers must collect several lots, and can only justify building if they can sell or lease a large number of units. The resulting structures typically have a cookie-cutter appearance, and don’t fit with the development patterns of many neighborhoods.
The units themselves have limited natural light and ventilation because they typically only have windows on one side. This, and the long corridors effectively mandated by code, actually pose a fire safety hazard due to how smoke travels and gathers.
Multi-stairway buildings also cost 6% to 13% more to build per square foot than single-stairway ones. The stairway rule contributes to the fact that multifamily housing is much more expensive to build than single-family housing in the U.S., which is nearly unique among developed nations. Reducing the cost of multi-family construction would go a long way toward mitigating the nation’s — and Pittsburgh’s — housing crunch.
Crucially, the Pew report demonstrates that attempts to relax stairway restrictions in American cities have resulted in no greater fire dangers to residents — as long as other modern safety features, like sprinkler systems, are present. In New York City from 2012 to 2024, the death rate in modern mid-rise (four-to-six-story) single-stairway buildings was the same as in all other multi-family buildings. And the few deaths Pew recorded had nothing to do with the single-stairway design.
U.S. building codes are outliers internationally. Many nations allow single-stairway buildings up to 20 stories and even higher. American experiments have been limited to increasing the maximum height from three to six stories.
There is good reason for this divergence. U.S. (and Canadian) construction is much likelier to rely on combustible materials, like timber, compared to European nations. Compartmentalizing structures with fire-proof walls is also much more common abroad than in America, which is more likely to rely, according to Pew, on “active” fire suppression technology such as sprinklers.
But what the Pew report shows is that those active strategies work, even in mid-rise single-stairway buildings. The high social and economic costs of the multi-stairway requirement have been known for many years, but they have appeared to be justified by their fire-safety benefits. The Pew report shows definitively that those benefits no longer hold, and certainly do not justify the costs.
As Pittsburgh looks to increase its affordable housing, legalizing mid-rise single-stairway residential buildings would allow for creative, dense infill that fits with existing development patterns. Such a change should be part of the push for housing reform that’s sweeping the city — and the nation.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.