A thorough audit by the office of Pittsburgh City Controller Rachael Heisler has revealed how the Department of Parks and Recreation’s vague policies and procedures for the use of purchase cards, or “p-cards,” led to widespread, but fortunately minor, misuse.
P-cards serve an important role for city employees, especially in Parks and Recreation (also known as Citiparks). They allow them to quickly purchase essential materials, which are not subject to the usual procurement rules, so events and other programming can be managed smoothly and efficiently.
Ms. Heisler’s audit found that many Citiparks employees and administrators did not know the city Office of Management and Budget’s rules, and that the vast majority of p-card purchases during the audit period were not authorized by those rules.
The misuse did not indicate a culture of corruption or self-dealing, but minor misuse could easily develop into actual abuse. More importantly, the audit points to a lack of communication and understanding in city government, which must be corrected.
The audit made intelligent recommendations for doing that. Citiparks leaders gratefully accepted these suggestions, and stated in their reply that they’ve already implemented several.
But the audit does not resolve — nor could it resolve, given its scope and the limited role of the Controller — some fundamental, and still unanswered, questions about the scandal that roiled city politics last year by which p-card misuse first came to light: the saga of Mario Ashkar. In fact, the overall lack of serious problems discovered in the p-card audit only makes the extent of the violations in the Ashkar case that much more curious.
It began last May when Ashkar was arrested for antisemitic vandalism in the Mexican War Streets, and an anonymous whistleblower indicated Ashkar was on the city’s payroll.
The Citiparks payments to Ashkar violated city policies — and possibly state ethics laws — in much more serious ways than the other items flagged in the audit. (To be clear, Ashkar is not personally suspected of wrongdoing in this matter.) The payments, apparently for services related to farmers markets, began as typical checks (subject to more precise City Council oversight) but shifted to the p-card, suggesting an intentional violation as opposed to the carelessness Ms. Heisler found elsewhere.
Further, the payments were clearly for a service beyond OMB regulations, were sent to a PayPal account that obscured the recipient’s identity and went far beyond the $10,000 annual limit for a single vendor. There are also remaining questions of fraud, as Gainey administration officials discussed — in emails released last year — backdating an invoice so it would appear to have been issued for work done prior Ashkar’s arrest.
We also still don’t know how Ashkar, who had been fired from the Department of Public Safety special events office just prior, came to the attention of Citiparks — a “revolving door” employment situation that may just barely skirt state ethics laws.
The Gainey administration has conspicuously avoided answering these questions, and buried its own inquiry in the Office of Municipal Investigations, which reports to the Mayor and used a tortured legal analysis to conclude that no rules violations had occurred — a conclusion belied by Ms. Heisler’s audit.
We also still don’t know the results of inquiries by District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr., whose investigators the city’s Department of Law attempted to stymie.
Pittsburghers can be grateful for Ms. Heisler’s work, and for the assurance that major p-card abuse is not systemic, and for Citiparks’ response. But this audit does not close the book on the scandal: If anything, it should remind us of just how much is still unknown.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.