While there’s more than enough dysfunction to go around in the Gainey administration, as this week’s resignation of Acting Police Chief Christopher Ragland demonstrated, an unusual share of that dysfunction has been related to the city’s Department of Law.
From playing games with District Attorney investigators looking into the p-card scandal to the truly embarrassing success rate in challenging the non-taxable status of real estate parcels, the law department has been part of numerous troubling episodes during the last three years.
Now comes perhaps the most incomprehensible legal action yet: attempting to claw back legal fees from the victims of the Fern Hollow Bridge disaster, despite the fact the city’s damages are capped under state law at a measly $500,000. It’s a kind of miserliness that simply doesn’t make sense — unless, of course, the city’s financial situation is far worse than Mayor Ed Gainey would like to admit.
None of these matters implicate the professionalism of the individual attorneys who staff the department, and who follow the directives laid out by City Solicitor Krysia Kubiak. But under the Gainey administration, the department has increasingly acted as if the mayor is its client, as opposed to the city and its people — that is to say, making choices that support Mr. Gainey’s political goals and narratives rather than strictly defending the city’s interests.
Tax-free farce
Take Mr. Gainey’s ill-fated attempt to hassle the city’s major nonprofits by challenging the tax-free status of their real estate, parcel by parcel. For the past year-and-a-half, the Editorial Board has reported that the project is a farce, freeing up far less in taxes than it has cost in outside counsel fees, let alone internal man-hours. Throughout, Ms. Kubiak has dissembled in front of City Council about the project’s success.
As of last March, the Editorial Board reported that only about $70,000 had been restored to the annual tax rolls, while City Council had approved $400,000 in outside legal fees. Last month, almost a full year later, WTAE-TV reported that the haul had only improved to $94,000.
At a budget hearing last November, Ms. Kubiak claimed the department had brought the work in-house before spending down the entire $400,000 allotment, which is good. But she also said she doesn’t track how much time attorneys spend on the nonprofit challenge project, making it impossible to know what the cost to taxpayers is in terms of other work not done, or done less well.
As for the hearings themselves, when a Post-Gazette editor attended a Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review appeal hearing last fall regarding Carnegie Mellon University parking lots, a young city attorney did her best, but was blown out of the water by the university’s counsel. Ms. Kubiak insists the city will do better in the Court of Common Pleas, where the BPAAR decisions will be appealed next, but there’s little reason to believe that’s the case.
It’s one thing to be ordered by the mayor to undertake a stupid project. It’s another to mislead council and the public about the success of that project to save face for the mayor, especially when the city’s home rule charter states the solicitor represents the city, not the mayor.
Squeezing survivors
While the Gainey-Kubiak law department spends more than it takes in on the nonprofit challenge project, it is also attempting to bilk Fern Hollow Bridge collapse survivors out of some of their tiny compensation.
The Editorial Board can confirm reporting from TribLive that last September’s claim of a settlement of nine lawsuits filed by people injured in the disaster was premature. It should have been a simple matter: State law caps municipal liability in torts claims at absurdly low $500,000 per incident, which means the victims should split that half-million dollars. City Council approved the payout last September.
But Jason Matzus, one of the plaintiffs’ attorneys, told a Post-Gazette editor he found out about that “settlement” from news media, not from the city. In reality, the city is still fighting the injured parties in court, including presenting arguments that drivers were negligent for failing to avoid plunging into the ravine. What can the city possibly gain from spending hundreds of man-hours on this litigation?
According to Mr. Matzus and others, the city wants the courts to deduct some of its own legal fees, from other pending litigation involving companies that worked on the bridge, from the $500,000 payout to the victims.
What could possibly justify so much effort for so little return? One possibility: Mr. Gainey and Ms. Kubiak lowballed her department’s 2025 budget to make the city’s finances look better than they are.
Budget reductions
Some of the most significant budget reductions for 2025 were in the law department, specifically outside legal fees and “judgements,” which includes everything from garbage-truck side-swipes to police violence claims. Mr. Gainey “saved” over $6 million by reducing the legal fees budget by $600,000 and the judgements budget by $5.5 million.
Last November, Ms. Kubiak justified this to council by arguing that the city had no major pending cases — and by saying outright that her team was attempting to get as many cases settled by the end of the year as possible, in order to keep the 2025 payouts low. In other words, to justify a lowball budget figure.
But it didn’t work. Many settlements approved by City Council in December didn’t get disbursed until January. Almost $1 million of the $1.3 million budgeted for judgements in 2025 has already been spent.
It’s easy to imagine a similar problem facing the outside legal fees budget, forcing the department to spend hundreds of its own man-hours trying to squeeze the Fern Hollow victims.
Altogether — not unlike the culture of the Trump administration — these episodes point to a traditionally apolitical unit of city government serving the political interests of the mayor rather than the interests of the people of Pittsburgh.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.