After the disastrous tenure of former Pittsburgh Police Chief Larry Scirotto, City Council must take a deliberative approach to vetting Mayor Ed Gainey’s next pick for top cop: Acting Chief Christopher Ragland. That means accepting Councilman Anthony Coghill’s request for a public meeting, as well as working with the Pittsburgh Branch of the NAACP, which has similarly requested a public forum with the chief nominee.

A press release Wednesday evening from the Black Political Empowerment Project confirming three community meetings is an encouraging sign that these requests are being heeded.

At the same time, council must not dither: After Mr. Scirotto’s abrupt and scandalous departure, the bureau has already experienced enough instability. Confirming — or declining to confirm — Mr. Ragland should proceed without substantial delay, so the police can focus on public safety rather than leadership drama.

That drama, and the necessity that council proceed carefully with this nomination, is ultimately rooted in Mr. Gainey’s fateful decision to hire Mr. Scirotto in the first place — and, in particular, to strike a secret deal with the chief that he could return to moonlighting as an NCAA basketball referee. That deception will likely cost the city over $1 million in pension expenses in the coming decades, and it shattered any remaining trust between the administration and the legislature — and the people of Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

Dishonesty debacle

Pittsburgh city government is suffering a crisis in credibility, exemplified by the amateur-hour handling of Mr. Scirotto’s selection and premature retirement. The story began in May 2023, when Mr. Gainey nominated the former Pittsburgh commander and Ft. Lauderdale chief to succeed Scott Schubert as the city’s top cop.

A curious fact that emerged while vetting Mr. Scirotto was that he had a passion for basketball, specifically officiating the sport at the highest levels of the college game. He had even traveled to referee while service as a law enforcement leader. This rightly concerned members of City Council, who asked Mr. Scirotto during his nomination hearing whether he would continue moonlighting during his tenure in Pittsburgh. He said that he wouldn’t. Mr. Gainey also affirmed this in public statements at the time.

Therefore it came as a surprise last October when Mr. Scirotto suddenly found himself on the court again. As the chief and the mayor attempted to explain themselves, they affirmed both that Mr. Gainey had approved Mr. Scirotto’s return to the court and that they had a gentleman’s agreement from the beginning that this would be acceptable.

In other words, both had misled council and the public, leading Mr. Coghill to rightly complain that Mr. Scirotto had been confirmed by council “under false pretenses.” It turned out great for the chief, though: After spending about 17 months as chief, he was eligible for a chief’s pension: over $90,000 a year, straight from Pittsburgh taxpayers. And since no crime was committed, there’s no legal way to claw those ill-gotten gains back for the people.

Broken bonds

It was a historic debacle, founded entirely on the dishonesty of Mr. Gainey and Mr. Scirotto. It left rank-and-file officers feeling betrayed and abandoned by both their chief and their mayor. And it left Pittsburghers rightly wondering if they could trust their government and its leader.

Advertise with us

This has only been heightened in recent weeks, as Mr. Gainey has told entirely different stories about his deal with Mr. Scirotto at different mayoral campaign events. One day, he said he told Mr. Scirotto he could referee if he reduced crime rates. Another day, he said he told Mr. Scirotto at first that he couldn’t referee, but changed his mind later.

This episode is why mayoral nominees are now required to be interviewed under oath by City Council, to raise the legal stakes of their statements. Mr. Coghill proposed this measure last month, and council passed it unanimously.

It is in this context, then, that Mr. Gainey has placed Christopher Ragland’s name forward to succeed Mr. Scirotto. Mr. Ragland has served as acting chief since Mr. Scirotto’s resignation last October. While there’s no special reason to doubt Mr. Ragland’s honesty, there’s every reason to reassure the public that the person most responsible for their safety is responsive to them — and that means holding a public hearing.

Restoring trust

If confirmed, Mr. Ragland will inherit a police bureau reeling from low staffing, low morale and low public trust. As Citizens Police Review Board executive director Elizabeth Pittinger has succinctly put it, the Pittsburgh police is becoming a “small-town department with big-city problems.”

That means the new chief’s number one priority must be recruitment: reversing the current state of attrition, with more officers resigning and retiring than signing up. And an essential part of that task will be restoring trust between the chief and the rank-and-file, and between the department and the people.

Advertise with us

That’s why, in addition to an under-oath interview with City Council, Mr. Ragland should also participate in public forum events, which appear slated to include participation from the local NAACP and other community groups to ensure concerns of people of color receive special attention. The best way to restore trust is face-to-face, and the best way to understand the community’s concerns is to hear them for yourself. How Mr. Ragland handles such an event should then inform councilmembers’ confirmation votes.

The past two years may not have been the darkest in Pittsburgh police history, but they have been among the most ridiculous. The next chief must be able to restore not just trust but professionalism and dignity to that office. And that means a thorough vetting by City Council, as well as the people of Pittsburgh.