Last Tuesday, the Pittsburgh City Planning Commission failed in its duty to provide independent guidance to City Council regarding massively consequential changes to the city’s zoning code. There was no good reason to choose between competing proposals by Mayor Ed Gainey and Councilman Bob Charland: Giving Mr. Gainey’s citywide inclusionary zoning (IZ) a positive recommendation and Mr. Charland’s affordability incentives a negative recommendation had nothing to do with evidence and expertise, and everything to do with power and politics.

Still, there were nuggets of wisdom to be picked up. Several commissioners, for instance, expressed hesitation about Mr. Gainey’s bill, and said that their supportive votes should be understood as an invitation for City Council to pursue a compromise package. This is exactly what Council President Daniel Lavelle should do.

It now falls to Mr. Lavelle to take the next step in the zoning ordinance process: scheduling a public meeting, which he must do within 120 days from the Planning Commission approval. That could, and should, take council beyond the contentious May 20 mayoral primary between Mr. Gainey and Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor. There is no reason to rush deliberations on zoning rules that could shape Pittsburgh for decades, nor should such a public meeting occur during a hyper-political campaign season.

This is especially true because the case for Mr. Gainey’s citywide IZ has yet to be seriously tested. At last Tuesday’s meeting, commissioners shut down a lengthy presentation by Mr. Charland and a UCLA housing expert, ostensibly because it was going on too long. However, this didn’t stop the commission from listening to hours upon hours of similar speeches from local activists, who brought lots of rhetoric and very little rigor to what’s supposed to be an expert panel.

Advertise with us

Commissioners did, however, force Gainey administration officials to admit that the local financial feasibility analysis its plan relies on is nearly a decade old. Needless to say, much has changed in the housing market in recent years. It’s the least City Council can do to request a new study based on contemporary conditions before making a final decision.

Inclusionary zoning is one of the most tested and studied housing policies in America. This board joins most experts in arguing that sweeping IZ with dodgy incentives for developers is likely to stifle growth, raise overall prices and result in minimal (or even negative) gains for deeply affordable housing. But some experts disagree, and Pittsburgh arguably offers some unique geographic and economic conditions wherein IZ could function differently than it does elsewhere. All these perspectives should be considered.

Thus far, though, the process has lacked intellectual rigor, especially in testing Mr. Gainey’s extravagant claims about IZ providing housing for everyone. Before holding any further public meetings, City Council should convene an ideologically diverse panel of outside experts — both from Pittsburgh and from elsewhere — so that its members can then engage with community voices in an informed and authoritative way.

All major zoning changes are among the most consequential votes any member of council will cast. Radically shifting the incentives for building housing could set the city’s course toward renewed prosperity or continued stagnation for decades to come. Before making a rash choice, there must be a compromise between the Gainey and Charland bills; there must be a new financial analysis; and there must be genuine consultation with the academics and practitioners who know housing best.

Anything else — and certainly rushing into a vote — would be malpractice.