An adjustment to the rules of Pittsburgh City Council proposed by Councilman Anthony Coghill of Beechview reflects deepening distrust in political institutions — and, in particular, deepening distrust between council and the Gainey administration. And it would, in a small but significant way, take a step toward restoring that trust by deploying an ancient concept with ongoing relevance: the oath.

In May 2023, Larry Scirotto appeared before City Council for a public interview, as part of council’s vetting process for the man picked by Mayor Ed Gainey to lead the city’s police force. At that meeting, Mr. Scirotto assured councilors — and, by extension, the people of Pittsburgh — that his days refereeing NCAA basketball games were behind him. While he had moonlit as an on-court official during his tenure in Ft. Lauderdale, he understood that the Pittsburgh job would require his undivided attention.

That was a lie. Barely a year later, Mr. Scirotto resumed refereeing with an exhibition game in the remote upper peninsula of Michigan, making him nearly unreachable in case of an emergency back home. In the ensuing imbroglio, Mr. Gainey revealed that the two man had agreed, from the very beginning, that the chief could return to officiating after a probationary period.

City Council clearly approved Mr. Scirotto’s hiring under false pretenses. Yet there were no consequences. Mr. Gainey allowed Mr. Scirotto to resign with dignity — and, given his year of service as chief, a fat increase to his pension, which will cost the city hundreds of thousands of dollars in the decades to come.

Advertise with us

The deception should feature in the upcoming mayoral primary, but political ramifications are clearly insufficient to incentivize honesty. That’s where Mr. Coghill’s bill comes in: If passed, it would standardize City Council’s procedure for interviewing candidates for department heads, including placing the candidates under oath. That would make lying to council — and, again, by extension the people of the city — not just a moral failing, but perjury.

The idea of the oath may seem quaint or old-fashioned, but it is the foundation of the American legal system — indeed, of any functioning system of justice. Justice must be based on truth, and those who administer justice must be able to trust that those who testify are speaking truthfully. That’s why perjury is a crime, and a very serious one.

An oath calls on a higher authority to witness to the truth of what is said. To break an oath, or to lie under oath, calls into question the veracity of the thing sworn upon, whether it’s divinity or the concept of justice itself. A society where oaths are taken lightly cannot long survive, at least in peace.

And even if a person doesn’t care about the oath itself, the consequences of perjury are far more concrete than those of simply lying in public. We should be able to trust that political leaders and their appointees will tell the truth because it’s the right thing to do. Obviously, we currently cannot.

Mr. Coghill’s proposal recognizes this unfortunate reality in city politics, and offers a way to rebuild trust: attaching real legal consequences to being untrustworthy. City Council has behaved naïvely toward the Gainey administration for most of the Mayor’s first three years in office. Now, councilors must take a step toward realism by passing Mr. Coghill’s resolution.