Mayor Ed Gainey’s “announcement” of a “commitment” by nonprofit Highmark Health to make annual payments to the City of Pittsburgh is a sham that only serves to underscore how little progress Mr. Gainey has made in securing tangible financial benefits from the city’s major nonprofits.

Among the most important unfulfilled promises is securing annual payments to the city from major nonprofits — especially the so-called Big 4 of UPMC, Highmark Health, the University of Pittsburgh and Carnegie Mellon University — which collectively own several hundred parcels valued at over $3 billion. Roughly one-third of city real estate is tax exempt.

Mr. Gainey’s predecessor, Bill Peduto, proved unable to secure the gold standard for nonprofit municipal contributions: payments in lieu of taxes, or PILOTs. In other cities with significant institutional footprints, such as Boston, PILOTs have contributed tens of millions of dollars to government coffers. These are meant to represent the public services used by major nonprofits, as well as a goodwill gesture to the city in which these institutions thrive.

However, Mr. Peduto did achieve a late breakthrough: the OnePGH program, which was a fund separate from the city and overseen by an independent board to which the city’s major nonprofits agreed to contribute. He made this announcement in the heat of a tough primary campaign (sound familiar?), and his challenger — then-state Rep. Ed Gainey — called it “too little, too late.” This board agreed, and urged Mr. Gainey to do better.

Advertise with us

Four years later, nothing has changed — except that Mr. Gainey’s “announcement” is even less impressive than Mr. Peduto’s.

The Highmark “commitment” is nothing more than a restatement of the position the organization has taken for several years: It is willing to make payments to the city as long as its peers do the same, based on a mutually agreeable scale. In the very statement Mr. Gainey touts as a breakthrough, Highmark indicates it’s nothing new: “As we have said in the past….”

Meanwhile, this is exactly the same position that UPMC — the Gainey administration’s white whale — has taken for several years. It’s a sneaky position, one that projects generosity while placing the onus on everyone else to play fair. It requires effective public leadership to translate these meaningless promises to a real shared financial commitment to the city and its people. Specifically, it requires the kind of leadership Mr. Gainey promised to provide.

This “announcement,” in demonstrating that precisely nothing has changed during Mr. Gainey’s more-than-three years in office, demonstrates his failure to do so.

And it also forces this board to look back on OnePGH more favorably than we did when it was announced. It was the product of years of intense negotiations, and it was far from perfect. We still believe that Pittsburgh deserves PILOTs, which could help to stabilize the city’s faltering finances.

But it was better than nothing — and nothing is all Mr. Gainey can show for his own efforts.