As America prepares to inaugurate its 47th president, today it mourns its 39th. James Earl Carter Jr. was born in 1924 and raised in rural Plains, Ga., before he rose to national and international prominence as a governor, then a president, and then, in his most inspiring turn, as a humanitarian. His story is one of the great American stories of the last century, itself the span of his remarkable life.
Carter at home
Every great story, of course, has its low points. He struggled to adapt to the political culture of Washington, D.C., and to respond successfully to the crises of the second half of the 1970s.
Domestically, the years from 1976 to 1980 (and beyond) are remembered for stagflation and a series of economic shocks, most notably the oil crisis of 1979, that sapped American confidence. Mr. Carter was dealt a tough hand, but didn’t play it well: His naïve and prickly relationship with Congress precluded the kind of bold moves that would reassure the country that strong leadership was at the helm.
At the same time, however, the Carter years did deliver some big policy changes that only bore fruit in the years after his presidency. For instance, natural gas deregulation and the creation of the Department of Energy, dedicated to researching and discovering domestic energy sources, laid the foundation for a new birth of American energy independence in the years to come. The National Energy Technology Laboratory site in South Park is a testament to this legacy.
Further, it was Mr. Carter who saw through the legislation that created the federal Superfund program, in response to the environmental tragedy at Love Canal, N.Y. In the following decades, Superfund has used billions of dollars to remediate hundreds of sites of environmental contamination around the country.
Carter abroad
Around the world, there’s no question Mr. Carter was a natural peacemaker — a virtue that shone through in the Camp David Accords, which normalized relations between Israel and Egypt after decades of tension and war. But there is more to being president, and in other areas he was unable to meet the moment.
He appeared feckless during the Iranian hostage crisis, and in responding to the Soviet Union’s war in Afghanistan. The responses Mr. Carter settled on — boycotting the 1980 Summer Olympics in Moscow, enforcing a grain embargo against the USSR and reinstating the Vietnam War-era requirement that young men register for the draft — hurt America more than its adversary.
Boycotting the Olympics denied hundreds of American athletes, as well as hundreds more from allied nations, the opportunity to compete for their country on the world stage. Later in life Mr. Carter admitted this had been “a bad decision.”
Meanwhile the grain embargo devastated U.S. farmers and, in a particular way, the Great Lakes ports through which that grain was shipped, which have never recovered. The Soviet Union simply sourced its grain from elsewhere.
And reinstating the Selective Service System — a move meant to signal toughness in an election year that nevertheless, and needlessly, persists to this day — did nothing to enhance America’s military readiness but did add another layer of bureaucracy that has been used by state governments, and the federal government, to deny benefits to young men who would otherwise qualify.
There is a historical trope of the good and decent person who is not a very effective leader, especially in hard times. Jimmy Carter was 20th-century America’s contribution to that tradition.
The Carter legacy
But even as Mr. Carter never seemed to be cut out to be president, he slipped into the role of post-president as if he were made for it. From 1980 until his death, he became the model of the elder statesman, traveling the world to conduct diplomacy and to marshal resources to relieve poverty and illness. In this role, he did his country great credit as its face and hands for millions, and even billions, of the poorest people in the world.
And while he became an international celebrity, Mr. Carter’s reputation and credibility was never for sale to the highest bidder. He wrote books and gave speeches — the usual post-presidency paid work — but (unlike his contemporaries) did not enrich himself based on his national service. Into his 90s, he still taught Sunday School at the Maranatha Baptist Church in his hometown of Plains, where he died more humbly than any president in recent memory.
That doesn’t mean he was a homebody. Through his NGO, the Carter Center, he was instrumental in (nearly) eradicating Guinea worm disease, a debilitating pestilence that had affected millions living in extreme poverty in Africa and Asia — until Mr. Carter’s campaign began. Cases of the parasitic infection have dropped into the dozens, instead of the millions.
In 2002, Mr. Carter received the Nobel Peace Prize “for his decades of untiring effort to find peaceful solutions to international conflicts, to advance democracy and human rights, and to promote economic and social development.”
For Mr. Carter himself, however, his greatest source of pride was certainly his 77-year marriage to Rosalynn, who preceded him in death in 2023. In their mutual fidelity, they provided a model for all Americans, and people everywhere, to admire and to follow.
From Plains to Atlanta to Washington to the world and back to Plains again, above all Jimmy Carter remained himself — a man of decency, of fidelity, of peace. He may not have been a great president, but he was something more important: a good man.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.