The third and final part of a series on troubling changes to Allegheny County’s residential mental health care system. You can find part two here. 

Ongoing changes to the system of residential mental health care in Allegheny County are further reducing the options for supportive living arrangements for people with serious mental illness (SMI), leaving care providers scrambling — and worried for the well-being of their clients and the communities they live in.

It’s another example of data-driven operations at the county’s Department of Human Services (DHS), which director Erin Dalton has endeavored to craft into the most analytics-based services bureau in America. But while its Mental Health Allegheny Housing Assessment has provided valuable insights, allowing the department to more accurately prioritize services, it cannot account for the on-the-ground reality of care for people with profound challenges and complex needs.

That’s according to numerous leaders and staff members of residential mental health facilities, who spoke with the Post-Gazette Editorial Board on condition of anonymity due to fear of reprisals from DHS. The department instructed providers not to discuss, even with their own staff, coming changes to their funding model, which will functionally end 24/7 supervised living arrangements in Allegheny County.

Advertise with us

While some clients may do better with more independence, many will not, and they and people who care for them, family and friends as well as professional care-givers, have said so. The pleas of service providers and the people they serve have fallen on deaf ears.

Replacing Mayview

The contemporary residential mental health care system in Allegheny County can be traced back to the 2008 closure of the last public inpatient facility in the county: Mayview State Hospital in Upper St. Clair.

Like so many other similar facilities, Mayview closed for a variety of reasons: One was a humanitarian response to the poor treatment of patients in a restrictive environment with little oversight. Another was the development of a new generation of psychotropic drugs, and a growing understanding of the possibility of long-term recovery for people with SMI.

Health professionals worried about what, if anything, would replace Mayview: In a letter to the Post-Gazette at the time, Beaver County psychiatrist Dr. Suzanne Vogel-Scibilia highlighted severe “service deficits,” including inadequate emergency room services and long waitlists for supportive housing. Others had seen patients from other psychiatric hospitals become homeless or incarcerated.

In response, a flexible system of community-based care was born in Allegheny County: Nonprofit contractors opened long-term structured residences (LTSR), community residential rehabilitation services (CRR), and 24/7 supportive housing (24/7 SH), among others. These categories include various levels of treatment and life-skills support, aimed at moving clients towards independence.

Advertise with us

Increasingly, researchers and mental health professionals have reassessed the continuum of care created in the wake of de-institutionalization, questioning if long-term stays in community group homes (such as CRRs) stultify rather than empower clients.

This work has generally proved inconclusive: While many people with SMI ask for greater independence, some report more isolation and higher instances of crimes committed against them. And most studies are focused on mitigating homelessness, not promoting recovery from SMI.

In other words, the available research neither militates against CRR-style group homes nor in favor of them as the only solution. But by cutting their funding in half, Allegheny County DHS is effectively ending licensed supportive group homes.

Blunt instrument

The department’s theory is that floating case workers can periodically check in on people with SMI living largely independently. This will ensure that services are attached to the person, and not to the facility, so the services can move with them — and not disappear when their circumstances change.

There’s good reason, in both academic research and on-the-ground experience, to believe that this model will work for many of the people currently housed in CRR homes. But the execution of the strategy has been marked by secrecy and an imperious attitude toward existing providers, as described by the providers themselves and demonstrated in a video briefing for providers viewed by the Post-Gazette Editorial Board, in which DHS leadership is dismissive of their concerns.

Advertise with us

In Allegheny County DHS, there is no sense whatsoever that the department’s leaders have anything to learn from on-the-ground service providers. They are considered impediments to data-driven reform, rather than partners.

Thus the department has deployed an extremely blunt instrument to achieve its ends: imposing a draconian 50% cut in the reimbursement for CRR services, from about $50,000 per bed per year to $25,000. This has forced providers to choose between radically cutting back their level of service or closing entirely. Meanwhile, providers say DHS has left them in the dark about what, if any, transition plans the department is deploying.

The result is uncertainty and distress, from facility leaders to staff to residents. Dozens of caretakers have been laid off, and clients have suddenly had to become accustomed to radically increased independence. Some will thrive. Some will not. And it’s unclear what help they will have.

Experimenting on Pittsburgh

Data can help us understand people, but people cannot be defined by data. The clients CRRs serve are complex: While the county’s assessment products can help prioritize resources for the clients as a whole, they can’t tell which precise services and living arrangements will help any individual thrive.

They also can’t account for how people become accustomed to a way of life, and how destabilizing it can be when supports are removed. As it stands, according to one CRR annual report reviewed by the Editorial Board, only 35% of patients complete the program, and rates of hospitalization, police involvement and injury are high.

Advertise with us

And that’s at 24-7-staffed facilities with established ties in residential neighborhoods.

DHS says most of the nearly 200 CRR residents in the county are ready for floating services. The people who work with them every day disagree, and say that gutting the system will hurt vulnerable people and further burden the county’s homelessness and public safety systems.

That’s our fear, too. While the gears are already in motion — one CRR in Shadyside closed on Saturday — we urge DHS to pause implementation until further study and a more complete public process can be completed. The department and its leaders must accept that data doesn’t tell them everything they must know, and that on-the-ground providers have insights they don’t.

Pittsburgh cannot be a laboratory for DHS experiments. It’s not fair to the people the department serves, and to the communities they, and all of us, call home.