As Donald Trump prepares to take office — and to empower billionaire businessmen Elon Musk and Vivek Ramaswamy to attempt to significantly reform the federal bureaucracy — the country will be forced to confront fundamental questions about the role of the U.S. government, including which tasks it currently performs could be performed by the private sector.
Already, two agencies have come under particular scrutiny: the United States Postal Service (USPS) and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA). The former appears to be a particular obsession of Mr. Trump and his Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), while the latter is discussed in the Project 2025 policy playbook from the right-wing Heritage Foundation.
Neither the USPS nor NOAA, however, are suitable targets for privatization. The tasks these agencies perform are of the kind that only an organization with a fully national public purpose and without a profit motive can perform effectively. This does not mean that they cannot be reformed — there is always room for greater efficiency — but they also cannot be eliminated without significantly harming public services.
In selecting Donald Trump for president, a plurality of Americans were aiming for better government, not bare-bones government. Mr. Trump and his advisors would do well to keep that in mind.
Neither snow nor rain
The Postal Service is one of the most common ways everyday people interact with the federal government — but, perhaps surprisingly, it’s also one of the most popular. A Pew survey conducted this July found that, among federal agencies, only the National Park Service (76%) had higher favorability than the USPS, at 72%.
This reflects an enduring intuition among the American people that, while they might find waiting in line at branches or dealing with damaged parcels to be frustrating, the USPS is an integral governmental responsibility. After all, the congressional power to establish a post office is specifically mentioned in the Constitution.
The reason for this is simple: The ability to send and receive mail — from greeting cards to bills to other important documents — is absolutely essential to the everyday running of the economy, and to Americans’ cohesion as a society. This is why the USPS is required by law to make mail accessible to people living at every legal address, typically by delivering right to their mailbox, but in extreme cases to a box at the nearest post office.
Only a federal government agency with such a legal mandate is suitable to provide such a service equitably and affordably. Private corporations, from UPS to Amazon, increasingly supplement this USPS service — but USPS also supplements their services by providing so-called “last mile” service to remote locales only the government can justify delivering to, because it has to.
Further, privatization dreams miss that the USPS is, in other ways, already forced by law to act like a business. It receives no federal funding: It’s supposed to fund itself entirely by fees. Deficits in recent years, however, have called this model into question: Given the agency’s expansive mandate and the changing nature of communications, forcing the USPS to forego taxpayer funding should be reconsidered.
None of this means that the USPS should be immune from criticism, and possibly even radical reforms. The Washington Post Editorial Board, for instance, has observed that as more and more communications have become digital, the volume of so-called “market dominant” mail — “items, such as first-class letters or marketing material, over which the Postal Service enjoys legal monopoly power” — delivered by the agency is shrinking. And over half of that is advertising — that is, junk.
It’s possible — indeed necessary — that the USPS of the future look different from the USPS of the past. But it must remain the USPS.
Forecasting the snow and rain
Privatizing NOAA may be even more fanciful. The data-collection and forecasting agency comes into for criticism in Project 2025 for contributing data that has bolstered what the document’s drafters believe to be climate change alarmism. The solution is to get the government out of measuring and predicting the flow of air and water altogether.
It’s hard to overstate how destabilizing that would be. NOAA and its subsidiaries, such as the National Weather Service and the National Hurricane Center, provide the information and forecasting on which businesses around the world, as well as millions of everyday Americans, depend.
In Pittsburgh, we’re accustomed to severe thunderstorm warnings from the NWS, but the agency also tracks water levels on the Three Rivers and their major tributaries, forecasting floods so people can prepare their homes and businesses or get to high ground. In larger bodies of water, NOAA predicts waves and currents, producing essential information for everyone from beachgoers to fishing boats to the container ships that move goods around the world. The agency also provides the maps and forecasts on which aviation depends.
All of this can and must be done without fear or favor to any person or organization. The public good is the only trustworthy motivation.
There already exist dozens of private organizations that supplement NOAA products with data and forecasting for specific applications, and perhaps their scope could be expanded further. But NOAA provides the foundation for all of them, while also handling the public-safety warning systems which the competitive marketplace could never replace. Imagine, for instance, competing sources for tornado or hurricane advisories, or having to pay for them.
While the free market is a remarkable tool for distributing goods and services, there will always be some tasks that are only suited to a national government whose purpose is to serve the public fairly and completely. DOGE can and should seek areas to streamline and simplify the federal government. But the USPS and NOAA must remain.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.