A new report from City Controller Rachael Heisler shows how casual use of p-cards isn’t just a problem in Pittsburgh city government. It’s also a bad habit in Pittsburgh Public Schools. (As the elected City Controller, Ms. Heisler also serves as School Controller.)
P-cards — also known as procurement or purchasing cards — are meant to be used by city and school employees to make generally small purchases that need to be made quickly. It would be senseless to require employees to submit such purchases to the typical, and sometimes arduous, procurement process.
Much of PPS p-card spending, for instance, is done by foremen leading teams of electricians, carpenters and so on. You shouldn’t need to put out an RFP to pick up a few bolts from Home Depot.
The Controller’s report notes that over the past few years, largely under the leadership of Superintendent Wayne Walters and Chief Financial Officer Ronald Joseph, the district has significantly cut back on the number of p-cards in circulation. While it’s clear there’s still work to be done to ensure not just the reality but the appearance of propriety in stewarding taxpayer resources, the momentum is in the right direction.
Ms. Heisler’s report spans the period from January 2021 to June 2024, and begins with the startling revelation that at the beginning of 2021 there were 738 p-cards in circulation among PPS employees — an absurd figure that cannot possibly be justified. In the period since, PPS opened 158 new cards and closed 433, bringing the total in use down to 463. In those three years, the cards were used nearly 60,000 times in transactions totaling $11.6 million.
The controller’s report shows how quickly the system can fail, even when it’s not being abused, once the habit of p-card use settles in. As with any public spending, someone should be performing regular audits.
When the school system had nearly 800 p-cards in circulation, such audits were nearly impossible to perform within the constraints of time and manpower, either at the district level or the controller’s level. It was a system that could have been very easily exploited or abused, but Ms. Heisler’s report found no evidence of systematic wrongdoing.
But she did find examples of inefficiency: In 2021, p-card purchases on Amazon became available in an effort to streamline the district’s buying. However, p-card holders began opening up Amazon Prime accounts associated with their cards, costing $13,000 dollars in unnecessary subscription fees — made even worse by the fact that district has its own Business Prime account.
In another case, the audit found that the small number of p-cards holders whose limits exceed $500 dollars for same-day purchases weren’t using this privilege in accordance with written guidelines. Instead, the 39 high-limit p-cards regularly made high-dollar purchases, necessitating a more formal oversight process.
Mr. Walters and Mr. Joseph have done good work in beginning to bring under control one aspect of the management of the very complicated Pittsburgh Public School system, and restructuring a system that had grown inefficient and unsupervised. Ms. Heisler has done equally good work in exercising one of the responsibilities of her office — as she did when she exposed clear examples of abuse in the city’s own p-card system, where the Gainey administration has chosen the path of obfuscation rather than transparency.
Meanwhile, as the school district continues to stare down financial oblivion, continued vigilance is necessary.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.