Donald Trump will enter office on Jan. 20 of next year with the most robust mandate for a Republican president since George W. Bush in 2004: a popular vote victory, plus majorities in both the House and Senate. But as Mr. Bush demonstrated, that mandate can easily be squandered. His second term is not remembered well, and resulted in John McCain’s shellacking by Barack Obama just four years later.
And so while this week’s results may feel sweeping — and remarkable swings to Mr. Trump in deep blue regions do suggest a historic populist realignment — they are not carte blanche for bad policy. It is clear that a critical mass of Americans want their government to work differently, and specifically to work more directly for them and their interests, but some of Mr. Trump’s key campaign proposals will have the opposite effect, especially regarding immigration.
At the same time, Mr. Trump’s election offers an opportunity for populist policies that will help everyday Americans, and that could even earn bipartisan support. In family and industrial policy, there is an opportunity to reorient the focus of the federal government toward working people and America’s distinctive economic and strategic interests.
There is understandable trepidation among many Americans about what a Trump administration will bring, and there is undeniable uncertainty about what the near-term future holds. But if the populist energies unleashed in recent years are channeled in a constructive way, they could lead to lasting change, for the better, for the country.
Against mass deportation
Above nearly everything else, the election delivered a clear mandate for stricter enforcement of U.S. immigration law. But whether that means the “mass deportations” Mr. Trump has promised is a more complicated matter.
As research by the University of Maryland’s Program for Public Consultation, with whom the Post-Gazette partnered during the campaign, has shown, there’s actually majority support in both parties for a path to citizenship for undocumented immigrants. Mass deportation is actually a minority position, especially in the swing states nearer the southern border. That’s because people there understand, more clearly than people in Pittsburgh where very few immigrants live, just how disruptive mass deportation would be.
From field labor to construction, undocumented workers are essential to the functioning of the American economy. It shouldn’t be this way: The U.S. should be able to enforce its laws, and undocumented status makes migrant vulnerable to exploitation. But it is this way, and removing this support from the American economy would result in an immediate contraction that would hurt all Americans: less food, less building, higher prices.
It would also be necessarily unjust and capricious. Any true “mass deportation” scheme would catch up legal immigrants and even U.S. citizens in the dragnet, and would almost certainly include ethnic profiling. Just as many native-born American might struggle to find documents like birth certificates that prove their status, many naturalized citizens don’t have their original paperwork, and could be subject to persecution and deportation. This is exactly what happened the last time the U.S. attempted such a program, when the offensively named Operation Wetback was launched in the 1950s.
At the same time, there is a clear and bipartisan consensus in favor of more strictly enforcing the U.S. border and verifying the legal status of workers in the U.S., in order to slowly wean the American economy off of undocumented laborers, who are easily exploited and undercut wages for American workers. The bipartisan immigration bill scrapped at Mr. Trump’s behest during the presidential campaign would be a strong step in the right direction, including funding for more Border Patrol officers as well as more personnel and resources to speed the adjudication of asylum claims.
For family and industrial policy
While mass deportation should be a non-starter, populist family and industrial policy could be a bipartisan winner for the Trump administration, and the American people. Indeed, if this is truly a populist movement, and not GOP business-as-usual in a populist costume, generous family benefits, which make it more realistic for people to consider having and raising children, will have to be part of the package.
This should begin with stopping the planned expiration of the Trump-era child tax credit expansion, then expanding it further. Early in his time as Mr. Trump vice-presidential nominee, Sen. JD Vance suggested a 150% expansion, from the current $2,000 to $5,000 per child. That should be the starting point for negotiations.
Child tax credit policy is often complicated by phase-in and phase-out provisions, as well as work requirements. But the simpler the program is, the easier it is to administer: Every family gets the same credit, with phase-outs for top earners, and they can opt to receive it in monthly installments directly to their bank accounts.
As for industrial policy, the Trump administration can build on its predecessor’s attempts to jump start U.S. manufacturing in strategic areas. That will mean prioritizing efficiency over bureaucracy.
The biggest piece of U.S. industrial policy in generations was the Biden administration’s CHIPS and Science Act, which was meant among other things to subsidize semiconductor manufacturing in the United States. But the law was bogged down with bureaucratic red tape, leading to projects stalling and several companies choosing to forego the subsidies to avoid the hassle.
This should be a lesson for future attempts at industrial policy. Federal officials have been acclimated to the endlessly complicated world of bureaucratic rules and regulations, and generally see no problem in adding a few dozen more here and there. But the resulting disconnect between policies and results only further cements the public’s distrust in the ability of their government, and their country, to do anything big and worthwhile.
A truly government will pursue policies that actually help the people. Mass deportation won’t. But generous family policy and intelligent industrial policy could be an important corrective for many years of neglect.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.