Earlier this week, City Controller Rachael Heisler released a report highlighting one of the underlying issues plaguing Pittsburgh Public Schools: weak and ineffective communication, both within the school board and with outside public agencies. As the school district enters a difficult phase of renewed school closures, it’s imperative that PPS opens up communication with city officials.
The health and well-being of the city and the school district are naturally intertwined — a fact recognized by City Council when it passed a bill creating a joint city-school partnership panel in 2022. Unfortunately, like so much else in Pittsburgh these days, nothing ever came of it, because the school board never approved the partnership itself.
As PPS’ most recent Facility Utilization Plan emphasizes, neighborhood schools are necessarily hubs of community, with partnerships and services that go beyond teaching reading, writing and arithmetic. But for this to be effective, it requires both a spirit and formal structures of collaboration between City Hall and PPS — something that has been proposed across several mayoral administrations.
Ms. Heisler’s report outlined areas in which the two government agencies’ duties regularly overlap: logistics like school safety, transportation and emergency childcare; summer and afterschool activities; and expanding educational offerings like universal early childcare.
These were also the areas mentioned in the original “City-School District Partnership” approved by City Council back in 2022. Their proposal would have set up regular meetings among the mayor, the council president, the controller, the superintendent, the president of the PPS board and others. Council cited the need to help students beyond school hours in the wake of the COVID pandemic, focusing on eliminating the spike in school truancy and the racial achievement gap exacerbated by school closures and other disruptions.
Having a scheduled quarterly meeting among PPS and city leadership would provide a necessary forum in which to address these issues collectively and efficiently. This idea is not new, and working relationships already exist informally between many education and policy professionals across Pittsburgh. But informal consultation is no substitute for regular meetings of an official — and publicly accountable — school-city panel.
When the idea was first floated in 2021, several councilmembers, including sponsor Rev. Ricky Burgess, lamented that city involvement in school pandemic response was way overdue. Meanwhile, school board member Kevin Carter even told local media that council doesn’t give “two cares” about the school district. Unfortunately the ordinance did not result in a new birth of trust: Despite the city ordinance, the new body has not been ratified by the school board, and therefore has not been formed.
It’s yet another example of government-by-gesture: promising that something will be done, then doing nothing until everyone forgets the original promise.
In the wake of the controller’s report, PPS released a statement indicating that they were “open” to collaboration with the city. It’s safe to assume that City Council was also open to collaboration when they unanimously approved the partnership back in 2022. So why isn’t it happening?
The one office the two bodies do share is the city controller’s: Ms. Heisler serves as controller for PPS as well as the city. So she is ideally suited to be the convener, and has performed that job well by making and releasing this report. The question is whether the cats will allow themselves to be herded by one of the few responsible voices on Grant Street.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.