After generating enormous public enthusiasm for pedestrianizing Market Square in Downtown Pittsburgh, the coalition of the Allegheny Conference on Community Development, the City of Pittsburgh and Allegheny County have had to abandon the plan and admit they made implicit promises they couldn’t keep. Ending vehicular access to the square is much more complicated than putting up a few barriers, which the coalition would have known had it seriously consulted the square’s business-owners and other stakeholders before pitching the idea in June as part of an “aspirational” bid to revitalize the Golden Triangle.

Reserving streets for people on foot almost always makes public spaces more welcoming and vibrant, and at first glance, Market Square looks like a perfect candidate for pedestrianization: Alongside PPG Plaza, it already feels like a kind of room within the urban core, a place set apart primarily for people to linger and to mill around. And it has all the amenities, especially outdoor dining, associated with urban pedestrian malls. Why not finish what was started last decade and close it off to cars entirely?

The problem is that the Downtown street grid makes it impossible to close only Market Square. If cars aren’t allowed in the Square, then Forbes must be truncated at Wood, because losing the square would create an unworkable dead-end. That would be perfectly fine — except Forbes provides access to a major office and hotel parking garage, which can’t be retrofitted to connect to any other street.

Further, Market Square merchants expressed concerns about deliveries of goods and customers grabbing take-out. These issues should not be insurmountable, but would likely require significant and expensive further infrastructure improvements. These clearly were not included in the original proposal — because no one seriously consulted the square’s business-owners.

Advertise with us

The truth is that the 2010 reimagining of Market Square was actually very well done. Removing the intersection at the center created a generous public space that accommodates everything from concerts and political rallies to farmers markets and an entire German-style winter market. Wide sidewalks provide ample space for dining and other uses, while paving the roads with Belgian block preserved access while calming traffic.

Spending millions of dollars to polish one of Downtown’s existing gems is not the best use of scarce public dollars: Smithfield Street and Mellon Square, for instance, could use much more attention.

But if we’re set on sprucing up the square, here’s a much simpler option: Close to car traffic the south half, nearest PPG Plaza. That preserves Forbes while opening more space to purely pedestrian use.

The collapse of one of the three legs of the conference-city-county Downtown plan goes to show that Allegheny Conference CEO Stefani Pashman was correct back in June to call the splashy proposal “aspirational.” Indeed, they might have taken a cue Donald Trump’s description of his health-care vision: “a concept of a plan.”

Whatever it is, it demonstrates once again that it’s amateur hour in the halls of power in Pittsburgh, while everyday people, as always, experience the consequences.