New data about the Pittsburgh region’s office market shows that suburban commercial districts and, above all, the so-called “Downtown fringe” of the Strip District and the North Shore are bleeding the Golden Triangle dry. This reflects years of complacency among the region’s leaders, especially after the onset of the COVID pandemic, and points to a future where Downtown Pittsburgh will look radically different than it does today.
Overall, the region’s office vacancy rate has declined, and compares favorably to benchmark competitors like Cincinnati and Cleveland — and very favorably compared to struggling St. Louis. About 16% of office space in Pittsburgh and its surroundings is available for lease or sublease, according to the report by the Colliers real estate firm.
But the story in the Golden Triangle is less rosy. While the “absorption rate” — which compares the amount of office space vacated and leased in recent months — across the Pittsburgh region has turned to the positive, the trend is the opposite Downtown, where 220,000 more square feet has been left than leased this year. The “availability rate” for office space in the central business district is nearly 20% (and other estimates peg it much higher), which is comparable to Cleveland and much higher than Cincinnati.
Meanwhile, several of the biggest moves in recent months have been out of Downtown to class A space — that is, top tier buildings that include on-site parking and major amenities like gyms and restaurants — in locations that have surpassed the Golden Triangle in desirability. That means Cranberry and Southpointe, but also the Strip, the North Shore and the East End, where modern offices with urban amenities are readily available.
In other words, Downtown Pittsburgh is no longer the premium location for offices in southwestern Pennsylvania. This phenomenon isn’t new, but the pandemic accelerated it. And while some regional institutions, like the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership, have been fighting to keep the Golden Triangle competitive, there’s no question the neighborhood has not been top-of-mind for the Gainey administration. The resulting complacency allowed Downtown to continue to lose ground against other compelling locations, while a reputation — partly fair, partly unfair — for dinginess and insecurity has continued to grow.
While regional leaders have generally been complacent about letting Downtown’s office culture wither, they also have struggled to articulate and advance an alternative vision for the neighborhood — except for a vague and anemic proposal to refresh a few public spaces from the Allegheny Conference on Community Development. Elsewhere, leaders are pursuing real visions. In a separate report this spring from the real estate company CBRE, Cleveland recorded the highest rate of office space conversions, whether to residential or mixed uses, anywhere in the country.
While Pittsburgh dithered in the face of a historic shift in the geography of work, Cleveland got a major head start — including public policies, such as tax credits, that made it possible to finance expensive conversion projects.
The Golden Triangle will likely never be Pittsburgh’s office mecca ever again. Indeed, some office buildings may have to be razed to make space for uses that better suit the present day. But it doesn’t have to continue to slide into decay. Pittsburgh’s downtown has advantages others don’t — geography, density, architecture. With an emphasis on public safety and a coordinated approach to economic development, Downtown can regain its footing as a commercial center while also transitioning to a become a more complete neighborhood.
But it will take a real vision, and real leadership, to get there.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.