The Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh has a deserved reputation among Pittsburgh contractors for arbitrariness, favoritism and opacity. The result is system of inefficient and overly expensive repairs and maintenance at the city’s largest provider of low-income housing, which lowers the living standards for the city’s most vulnerable residents.

Now the Post-Gazette Editorial Board has reviewed a third unusual and dubiously legal renovation contract the authority has approved, this one regarding apparent overpayment for roofing services. Meanwhile, this week the authority posted a request for proposals for “executive search and recruitment services,” suggesting that executive director Caster Binion is about to leave.

The authority’s board, chaired by Mayor Ed Gainey’s chief of staff Jake Wheatley, will be voting on revised procurement policies at today’s Sept. 26 meeting. But neither new policies nor Mr. Binion's departure will fix the problems that are shielding the process from scrutiny.

Hiding the ball

Take the “independent cost estimate” (ICE), which is meant to guide procurement decisions but is no longer disclosed by the agency.

Advertise with us

The ICE is a calculation of the reasonable cost of a service to be provided, and the authority is only supposed to choose vendors with prices above 75% or below 110% of the ICE, unless there are extraordinary circumstances. Several years ago, the authority regularly included the ICE in the public resolutions on which board members voted to authorize contracts, along with explanations when vendors were accepted outside the usual range.

However, in response to questions from the Post-Gazette Editorial Board, the HACP reports that “in 2018 the Board of Commissioners requested that the Independent Cost Estimates (ICE) be removed from the formal board resolutions and included only in the resolution summary documents.” These “summary documents” are not available on the agency’s website, making it impossible to judge whether the authority is getting a good deal.

Last February, when the board approved a split contract for roofing services across HACP properties, the authority definitely did not get a good deal — by its own choice.

Split personality

For several years in a row, the HACP had contracted with Pleasant Hills-based Vaughan Brothers, also known as Vaughan Roofing, for its roofing repairs across its properties. But last January, the authority received two bids for its new roofing contract: one from Vaughan, and another from a company with an Altoona address called White Water Painting.

The Vaughan bid came in at $432,000, while the newcomer White Water came in at $911,520. Yet when the HACP board considered the roofing contract, it awarded the work to both companies.

Advertise with us

It is mathematically impossible that both bids could be within the range of 75% to 110% of the independent cost estimate. However, the ICE is not mentioned in the board resolution approving the contract, which only indicates that “White Water Painting and Vaughan Brothers Inc. were determined to be the most responsive and responsible bidders.” There is no indication why two companies, with widely varying price points, were selected, when previously only one had been sufficient for the authority’s roofing services.

In response to the Editorial Board’s questions, the HACP acknowledged this acceptable range, but added (quoting the agency’s handbook) that “the Contracting Officer has the authority to ‘determine that the proposed price is fair and reasonable’ and will make a determination on what is in the best interest of the Authority that may include cost considerations and the capacity of the vendor.” But these determinations are completely opaque, and it’s very difficult to imagine what would justify accepting two bids when one is more than twice the price of the other — and when only one firm has held the contract for many years.

White Water, for instance, is not a minority- or woman-owned business, so adding it to the contract doesn’t address any diversity goals.

Further, there is no evidence that Vaughan’s work has been unsatisfactory, but there is evidence White Water was not up to the task. Last October, while working under this contract, White Water was fined $2,800 by the federal Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) for a “serious” violation at the Bedford Dwellings complex in the Hill District. The standard violated by the firm was the “duty to have fall protection and falling object protection.”

Vaughan, on the other hand, has no OSHA violations for as long as public records exist, back to 1972.

Advertise with us

Reputation management

Whatever the explanation for splitting this contract between vendors with wildly different prices, taken in context with other unusual contracts approved by HACP it adds more detail to a portrait of a public agency operating without transparency and, therefore, with impunity.

The Post-Gazette Editorial Board has previously revealed that HACP split a long-time security contract with a newcomer firm, which is owned by Republican candidate for state Senate Jen Dintini and whose employees are part of the politically powerful SEIU 32BJ union, even though the original firm was rated the most responsive and responsible.

The agency also received approval from the city’s Equal Opportunity Review Commission for a plan to split a landscaping contract between a local minority-owned business and an Elk County company — then one week later ditched the local firm and awarded the entire contract to the distant competitor.

Now the HACP appears to be quietly preparing for the departure of its executive director, while voting on a revised procurement policy. But no written policy matters if it can be violated with impunity. These moves give the appearance of responsiveness and accountability without the reality, and it’s not good enough.

The HACP houses over 18,000 Pittsburghers, or about 6% of the city’s population. The agency’s practices are relevant to the entire Pittsburgh community, and it certainly has a role to play in alleviating the city’s ongoing crisis of housing affordability. But that will require trust and transparency, not to mention professionalism, to accomplish.

In its handling of basic maintenance and upkeep contracts, the agency and its board are not demonstrating these qualities.