A recent letter by Pittsburgh real estate attorney Jonathan Kamin, explaining the dubious legality of the proposed citywide expansion of “inclusionary zoning,” should give City Council all the impetus it needs to separate IZ from an otherwise exemplary package of zoning reforms from Mayor Ed Gainey. There is no need to hold forward-thinking reforms hostage to a ham-fisted affordability mandate that is likely to be struck down in the courts.

Unfunded IZ mandates — Pittsburgh’s would requires that all developments of 20 or more units put aside 10% of units of affordable housing — have proven to be poor policy from every angle. The city neighborhoods where IZ has already been implemented have not seen a surge in affordable housing. Instead, growth has stalled, and projects have downsized to avoid triggering its requirements, exacerbating the very problem IZ was meant to address.

Besides being ineffective at achieving its stated goals, for the last two years IZ has also faced legal challenges from the Builders Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh. These arguments were recently underscored by Mr. Kamin in a letter to LaShawn Burton-Faulk, chair of the Pittsburgh Planning Commission.

The legal argument against IZ is simple: Imposing an affordability requirement, which generally costs developers about $250,000 per unit, significantly diminishes the value of real estate owned by existing property owners. By forcing a private developer to take this loss in the service of a public policy goal, this represents an uncompensated “takings” by government fiat — a violation of the Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.

Advertise with us

Whatever one thinks of this argument, it’s one likely to get a favorable hearing from the U.S. Supreme Court, where six members represent conservative schools of interpretation that are highly suspicious of public encumbrances on private property owners. Spreading IZ citywide even as the city’s existing unfunded mandates are litigated is imprudent in itself; tying legally dubious and development-killing IZ to a slate of reforms that will make Pittsburgh a better place in which to build simply doesn’t make sense.

Indeed, Mr. Kamin — who does count development firms in the city among his clients — also provided in his letter a clear-cut example of how quickly a developer threw in the towel after applying the city’s IZ regulations. The cost projections of a 150-unit development showed that IZ would have immediately devalued the project by about $4 million. To cover this new cost, the developer would have needed to borrow more, with the final calculation rendering a loss of $543,000 a year. Pittsburgh city government can do many things, but it can’t force a firm to build a project that doesn’t make financial sense. So the developer simply decided to move their project to Ohio.

It’s particularly upsetting seeing the Gainey administration continue to pursue failed and destructive affordability-by-fiat when its other proposals are so sensible. The other zoning amendments would abolish parking minimums, allow for more creative uses of small lots, open up avenues to build so-called “granny flats,” and permit higher density allowances near transit hubs. These will enhance Pittsburgh’s overall prosperity while liberating property owners to build more efficient and affordable housing. IZ will do the opposite.

Mr. Kamin called for the Planning Commission to request a legal opinion regarding the IZ proposal. This is both legally and politically prudent: It gives Council a chance to do the right thing and pass Mr. Gainey’s other zoning reforms while holding — and ultimately killing — citywide IZ.