A slew of changes to Pittsburgh’s zoning code proposed by Mayor Ed Gainey this week includes several time-tested, expert-approved and forward-thinking improvements: removing minimum parking requirements, higher density allowances near transit hubs, updating residential lot size regulations and allowing accessory dwelling units (sometimes called “granny flats”) in many residential districts.

These reforms would have the potential to revolutionize Pittsburgh’s land use, unleash residential development and bring housing prices down across the board, especially for renters.

Unfortunately, however, Mr. Gainey attached to the reform package a radical policy that defies experience and expertise, and that would neutralize all the gains in housing availability and affordability from the other proposals: expanding so-called “inclusionary zoning” citywide. While the administration has made the IZ expansion central to its zoning reform push, City Council must fight hard to detach it from the much more constructive proposals.

Great leap forward

Like many cities nationwide, Pittsburgh is facing a severe residential housing crunch. A 2022 city-led study found a shortage of over 8,000 units for the city’s poorest renters, due in part to housing policies — including restrictive zoning — that have left low-income, and especially Black, residents behind.

Advertise with us

Most of the Gainey administration's zoning changes represent real improvements, focusing on reforms to outdated rules that make it unnecessarily difficult to build creatively in the city.

These include abolishing minimum parking requirements, which drive up the cost and scale of proposed developments, including their footprint in the cityscape. This doesn’t mean eliminating parking entirely, but liberating builders to set aside parking space suitable to the development and its neighborhood surroundings, rather than forcing them to conform to a one-size-fits-all approach.

Other reforms would allow building on smaller lots, and closer to the edges of property, to allow for denser development while tucking more buildings into Pittsburgh’s unique geography.

Particularly encouraging is a measure that would upzone — that is, permit taller and denser construction — around transit hubs. The best example is South Hills Junction, currently surrounded by old Port Authority (now PRT) land with largely single-family housing beyond. Transit-oriented development like this boosts transit ridership and gets more people living in and moving around the city, while minimizing increased vehicle traffic.

Meanwhile, legalizing accessory dwelling units, or secondary buildings built alongside homes, across the city gives residential property owners the flexibility to build on their own lots, either to house friends and family or to rent. Allowing ADUs increases the supply of available housing in the city.

Advertise with us

Poison pill

While the Post-Gazette Editorial Board has been consistently critical of Mr. Gainey’s performance as mayor, this slate of zoning reforms required a tremendous amount of detailed work, and reflects a bold and thoughtful reimagining of land use in Pittsburgh. If these reforms were to be passed alone, it would be by far the most important achievement of Mr. Gainey’s administration — progress that would be the mayor’s legacy for decades to come.

Unfortunately, Mr. Gainey has chosen to make these reforms contingent on the city also swallowing a poison pill: citywide inclusionary zoning (IZ).

IZ refers to policies that require developers to set aside a portion of new multifamily housing units for low-income residents. In Pittsburgh’s proposal, any developer building over 20 units will be required to set aside at least 10% for people making less than half of the area’s median income, or roughly $17 an hour.

On the surface, this seems like a way to create economic diversity in new development, to slow gentrification and to ensure that residents of all income levels can enjoy the same neighborhoods and amenities. If it reliably achieved those goals, we would support it.

In practice, however, unfunded IZ — that is, mandates without public subsidies to offset the cost to developers of the affordability set-asides — has been consistently shown to reduce overall housing supply, stifle development of all kinds (including affordable) and therefore contribute to the housing shortages that drive prices higher, especially for renters.

Advertise with us

Cities that experimented with broad unfunded IZ, like Portland, Ore., have since rolled them back. In Philadelphia, the results of an IZ overlay in high-growth neighborhoods threw such a wet blanket on residential development that the editorial page of the Inquirer urged the city to repeal it. And IZ presents even bigger problems in low-growth cities like Pittsburgh, where it would smother hope for a residential building renaissance.

Not a new proposal

In fact, Pittsburgh already has an IZ overlay — that is, neighborhoods where IZ requirements are layered on top of existing zoning rules. The first IZ neighborhoods were the hot markets of Lawrenceville and Bloomfield in 2019. And results have been predictable.

Since the implementation of IZ, only one development of over 20 units has been built in these neighborhoods. In particular, IZ combined with strict zoning limitations to kill off a promising development of nearly 250 apartments at the Community Market site in Bloomfield, which will now remain a barren field of asphalt for years to come. And as with so many cities with similar regulations, developments of 19 units — just enough to avoid the IZ requirements — are popping up.

Because Pittsburgh’s IZ mandate is unfunded, the cost of subsidizing units is shouldered by developers, to the tune of about $250,000 per unit. Some Pittsburgh activists, including Councilwoman Barb Warwick, have argued that the city’s existing patchwork of housing vouchers and tax abatements funds the IZ affordability requirement. But the evidence of Pittsburgh’s existing IZ overlay demonstrates that it is not working.

For those who need affordable homes now, public and private stakeholders should continue to generate creative solutions. But affordability by government fiat through IZ, while simple and appealing, simply doesn’t work. In fact, it makes the problem worse. City Council should pass the Mr. Gainey’s visionary zoning reforms, and preserve their effectiveness by killing inclusionary zoning.