A so-called “fair housing” amendment to Pittsburgh’s zoning code is winding its way through the labyrinth of city politics, but what it will actually do — and why it’s needed — remains obscured by bureaucratic jargon and euphemisms. That’s because what it will do is likely to be very unpopular, even if it is the right thing to do.
Specifically, the amendment will remove significant barriers to adding more homeless shelter and transitional housing capacity in neighborhoods around Pittsburgh. This is an important step toward relieving the burden on existing facilities, and on the city’s public spaces that have been rendered dangerous or unusable by encampments.
However, this effort must be accompanied by honest communication with the public, as well as coordinated efforts among the city, Allegheny County and the nonprofit sector to provide services at shelter locations that will minimize the effects on surrounding communities — while maximizing the likelihood of getting unhoused people back on track. Sneaking big changes under the radar will undermine the cause of care for the homeless by stoking community opposition. If Pittsburgh is going to successfully address its crisis, as many people and institutions as possible will need to be on board together.
Three changes
Very few Pittsburghers know that sweeping changes to the city’s zoning code were considered at the last meeting of the Planning Commission on July 23, and that the commission will hold a public hearing on the amendments on Tuesday, Sept. 3. And of those who are aware of the proposed changes, even fewer understand what they are and what they mean.
For the sake of simplicity, here we will focus on the three changes that will have the biggest effects on the ability to provide housing for the currently unhoused: redefining and adjusting permissions for “personal care home” uses; creating the “interim housing” use; and allowing one type of group residential use, such as a convent, to be transferred to another kind of use, such as a shelter.
The first change will significantly expand the areas of the city where shelters and other congregate living facilities, such as single-room occupancy or some half-way houses, can exist without public meetings or special exceptions. Under the proposed amendment, small facilities for 10 or fewer people would be permitted by right — that is, no questions asked — in nearly every zoning district, including all residential areas. Currently, these facilities are only allowed with a special exception, which requires a public hearing of the Zoning Board of Adjustment.
Larger facilities would be newly permitted by right in almost all commercial and mixed-use districts, and with a special exception in denser residential districts, excluding single-family housing zones. Altogether, this will mean congregate housing will be much easier to place in more locations across the city.
Tiny houses, but not tents
The amendments also create a new use: “interim housing.” This use encompasses “temporary” measures to relieve homelessness, and would be permitted with a special exception in all districts that currently allow hotels and motels. That means nearly all commercial, industrial and mixed use districts.
The “interim housing” designation would allow for projects such as the “tiny house” communities that have been stalled within the Planning Commission for nearly a year. Councilors Anthony Coghill and Deb Gross have withdrawn their plan while these amendments are considered, but they should resubmit it once the new zoning rules are set. It’s one of the few creative solutions for homelessness that have come out of city government in recent years.
However, in response to a question on the city’s public engagement website, senior planning manager Kate Rakus acknowledged that tent encampments could also constitute legal “interim housing.” As we’ve previously argued, formally sanctioned encampments would represent a tremendous liability for the city. They also become hubs of illegal activity, as bad actors take advantage of the density of desperate people to stash and sell their illicit products. “Interim housing” should only include formal temporary structures, like the tiny houses.
Lastly, the most arcane change may be among the most important: allowing one type of institutional use to transition to another with only an internal bureaucratic review. This would allow, say, a defunct assisted living facility to become a single-room occupancy facility for housing-insecure people with only the approval of the city’s zoning administrator, and no public hearings or meetings. This would significantly smooth the process of bringing old facilities back on-line to fill contemporary needs.
Community engagement
It’s clear that these proposals are meant to clear away some bureaucratic hurdles to expanding the city’s ability to house the homeless. They are also presumably meant to help facilitate County Executive Sara Innamorato’s 500 in 500 days housing plan. With a narrower definition of “interim housing,” they should pass.
However, removing or limiting requirements for public hearings must not mean placing aside community engagement. Whether it’s turning a convent into a shelter or approving a small recovery home in a residential neighborhood, these facilities will only succeed if the city, the county and service providers have honest conversations with the surrounding community.
That may include making some concessions, like promising police patrols or relaxing some requirements that shelters be “low-barrier.” It absolutely means providing reliable transportation to and from the facilities to avoid daytime loitering. The success of these programs, and therefore the stability and well-being of the people they serve, will depend in large part on the goodwill of the surrounding residents. That means having candid conversations, and making thoughtful compromises.
Right now, however, the “fair housing” amendments are largely wrapped in bureaucratic jargon. When they emerge from the Planning Commission to City Council, their full ramifications must be the subject of significant public engagement — and not just a simulcast council hearing. There should be in-person neighborhood meetings in each council district, at the very least.
These changes may be necessary — but if they are sneaked through, they will fail.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.