The Gainey administration’s evasive, opaque and downright suspicious behavior in response to the misuse of a city credit card (purchase card, or p-card) has turned what might have been a small indiscretion into a growing scandal. To all appearances it has become yet another example of the classic lesson: The cover-up is worse than the crime.

The administration, despite its protestations of cooperation, has clearly attempted to stonewall multiple independent investigations — first from City Controller Rachael Heisler, now from District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. And its in-house investigation was so limited as to be practically useless, except at further exposing how little Mr. Gainey and his inner circle want to reveal.

Every attempt to explain how Mario Ashkar came into the city’s service, to be paid using an unauthorized and easily hidden method, and came to be separated from the city has been woefully and obviously incomplete, leaving unanswered more questions than it resolves — and often raising new ones. Something is missing, and whatever it is, the Gainey administration doesn’t want anyone to find it.

That’s exactly why the public needs Ms. Heisler and Mr. Zappala to continue to seek the truth.

Advertise with us

How we got here

The p-card scandal emerged after the arrest of Mario Ashkar in an incident of antisemitic vandalism in the Mexican War Streets in April. They (Ashkar uses they/them pronouns) agreed to a tentative deal earlier this month, avoiding jail time.

This turned out to be only the beginning of a much more complicated story.

In 2021, under the stage name Princess Jafar, Ashkar was a somewhat prominent social media critic of former Mayor Bill Peduto. Shortly after Ed Gainey defeated Mr. Peduto, the Department of Public Safety hired Ashkar as an “events coordinator,” but let them go in December 2022. The next summer, the Department of Parks and Recreation began paying Ashkar to provide unspecified services for the city’s farmers market program.

After one payment via invoice and check — the appropriate form for paying contractors — the department, under the leadership of Director Kathryn Vargas, began paying Ashkar at a PayPal account using a city p-card. In May, an anonymous source tipped off Ms. Heisler in the wake of Ashkar’s arrest, leading to the initial inquiries.

Several weeks later, revelations in public documents demonstrated that Ashkar, apparently at the direction of city employees, submitted two separate invoices for their last days working for Parks and Recreation. The second invoice removes hours worked after Ashkar had been identified by police as a suspect in the vandalism, but adds other hours. It gives the appearance of retroactively adjusting paperwork to bring it into line with a more convenient timeline of events — that is, fraud.

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, the Gainey administration resisted the Controller’s investigation, ultimately opening one of its own — with an extremely limited mandate — through the Office of Municipal Investigations.

What it means

What we know about the p-card mess raises numerous questions, many of which were posed by Ms. Heisler in the early days of the scandal. Almost none of them have been satisfactorily answered by either the Gainey administration or the OMI investigation.

That’s because the internal investigation — which the administration used to justify withholding information from both Ms. Heisler and Mr. Zappala — was given a narrow mandate that excluded all the most interesting, and potentially damning, aspects of the scandal. OMI only looked into whether Ms. Vargas’s use of the p-card to pay Ashkar violated city policies, ensuring that no other irregularities, and no higher-ranking officials, came under scrutiny.

OMI’s conclusion that Ms. Vargas didn’t violate the city’s p-card rules because Ashkar’s services were not “professional” in nature is also deeply troubling, as it rests on a very narrow definition of “professional” that creates a gaping loophole for more unaccountable city transactions.

But it’s what OMI didn’t probe, because it wasn’t told to probe, that really raises concerns. How did Ashkar come to be hired by Public Safety in the first place? Why is there no written documentation of Ashkar’s arrangement with Parks and Recreation? Did Ashkar receive special treatment?

Advertise with us

Why were top officials like Office of Management and Budget Director Jake Pawlak and Chief Operating and Administrative Officer Lisa Frank — on whose block the antisemitic vandalism occurred — copied on emails about an individual Parks and Recreation contractor? Did anyone direct Ms. Vargas to run roughshod over payment rules, or to backdate Ashkar’s last invoice?

At a Wednesday press conference, skeptical journalists asked Mr. Pawlak if anyone in the Mayor’s Office helped Ashkar get his jobs with the city, or intervened in this matter in other ways. He would only give his personal assurance that no one had. That’s not good enough. That only raises suspicion further.

What’s next

This week, the stakes were raised when Mr. Zappala’s office served a search warrant on the city for documents from the OMI probe the Law Department refused to cough up. The probable cause affidavit — Mr. Zappala successfully convinced a judge he had good reason to believe the administration was concealing evidence of a crime — describes Solicitor Krysia Kubiak as stonewalling the DA’s office for weeks, including brazenly not returning phone calls and sending a deputy to bluster for her.

The misuse of the p-card was bad, but it wasn’t a disaster. A thorough and transparent investigation likely would have resolved it quickly. Maybe an employee or two would be disciplined, even terminated.

But the Gainey administration is acting like the scandal is much worse. And in so doing, it’s making the scandal much worse.

Something is missing that would explain much, or all, of what we don’t know about this scandal. Whatever it is, the administration is hiding it — and it must be found.