Downtown Pittsburgh faces many challenges on multiple fronts. The area’s working population has yet to rebound to the numbers coming into the city to work before the pandemic, with all the knockon economic effects, including collapsing property values reflected in recent tax reassessments. Added to this, the city’s ongoing homelessness crisis has left certain areas feeling apocalyptic, keeping visitors and shoppers away.

So when a firm com­mit­ted to Down­town man­ages to em­bark on a dif­fi­cult preser­va­tion proj­ect while re­tain­ing ba­si­cally all of its ten­ants, the re­spon­si­ble own­ers should be com­mended. New Jer­sey-based Rugby Realty, the owner of Down­town’s Gulf Tower as well as the his­toric Frick and Kop­pers build­ings, has man­aged to uti­lize the build­ings in its port­fo­lio to re­tain ten­ants while si­mul­ta­ne­ously ret­ro­fit­ting its 44-story art deco sky­scraper.

Most im­por­tantly: Rugby’s ten­ants have over­whelm­ingly opted to stay Down­town. Law firms like Robert Peirce & As­so­ci­ates have signed leases in the nearby Frick Build­ing, while oth­ers will move to the Kop­pers Build­ing. Rugby has given ten­ants am­ple time to re­lo­cate — in­ter­est rates and con­struc­tion prices are high, so there’s no pres­sure to be­gin build­ing im­me­di­ately.

This is the re­sult of keen plan­ning, smart part­ner­ships, and a re­laxed time­line to com­plete the $200 mil­lion proj­ect. The pro­posed con­ver­sion will cre­ate 226 res­i­den­tial units — 27 af­ford­able — on floors 11 to 38, and a 126-room lux­ury ho­tel. Rugby aims to le­ver­age the city’s 10-year tax abate­ment pro­gram for res­i­den­tial con­ver­sions as well as $10 mil­lion through a state re­de­vel­op­ment as­sis­tance cap­i­tal grant.

Advertise with us

None of this success was guar­an­teed, or even expected. The Gulf Tower had been emp­ty­ing out since a 2021 fire shut it down for nearly six months, making the turnaround all the more impressive.

Down­town’s fu­ture re­mains un­cer­tain. There are still no eco­nom­i­cally vi­a­ble solu­tions to spare the BNY Mel­lon tower, Down­town’s sec­ond larg­est, from the wreck­ing ball. Re­as­sess­ments of some of the big­gest sky­scrap­ers in the Golden Tri­an­gle have slashed val­u­a­tions by nearly half a bil­lion dol­lars for the 2022 and 2023 tax years.

These is­sues are se­ri­ous and de­serve at­ten­tion. But Pitts­burgh’s down­town is not a lost cause. The area’s un­cer­tain fi­nan­cial fu­ture and pop­u­la­tion strug­gles don’t ne­gate the thriv­ing ame­ni­ties. Both things can be true in the heart of a city.

Lo­cal gems like the Benedum Center and Heinz Hall, not to men­tion the nearby sta­di­ums and riv­er­front ame­ni­ties, have kept Down­town con­nected and bus­tling. The work of firms like Rugby Realty, and their own­er­ship’s ex­cep­tional com­mit­ment to Down­town, of­fer hope in the com­ing de­cades.

Rugby has also proven that the tran­si­tion to­wards smaller of­fice foot­prints and res­i­den­tial con­ver­sions don’t in­ev­i­ta­bly lead to a tenant purge. We hope that other Down­town build­ing own­ers take note.