Pittsburgh Public Schools’ inevitable school consolidations were always going to be a complex and painful process, which means that the consulting firm the city hired to handle the proposals should have respected parents enough to show their research, rather than just asking them to trust a process that many feel has been opaque from the beginning.

At a meeting on Tuesday, it took Massachusetts-based consulting firm Education Resource Strategies two hours and 17 minutes to unveil their the actual plans regarding school closures and consolidations. Productive conversations couldn’t begin before then.

Up until that point, the talking points had only revealed the obvious. Pittsburgh schools should be “focusing our plans on preparing PPS students for the future” one slide read.

Community members want their children to be safe, supported, and have access to as many educational opportunities as possible. They want equitable access to amenities like gyms and air conditioning, discipline that is consistent, and fair grading practices.

Advertise with us

The city paid $248,270 for that. Out of context, it would have been impossible to know that this was a meeting regarding imminent school closures affecting dozens of schools, in a school district whose budget deficit will reach $23 million this year, serving 18,380 students in facilities meant to house 40,000.

The meeting’s absurdity was not lost on school board members. School Board member Sala Udin, over half an hour into proceedings, was the first to ask exactly why no one was addressing the elephant in the room: school closures. Even after the subject was tentatively broached a full hour in, the consulting firm obliquely referred to the massive overhauls as “portfolio changes.”

For all the talk of honoring the community members and parents involved in the process, ERS had a breathtaking lack of respect for their time, patting itself on the back for 40 minutes before slowly moving into more important information. It also seemed unable, or unwilling, to go over the history of PPS’ budget issues, taxing complexities, revenue shortfalls, or hard numbers about student demographics.

Parents understand the problems PPS is facing. They know those problems will affect not just where their children go to school, but class sizes, staff numbers, and course offerings.

Joe Trawick-Smith of ERS told the audience they should “poke holes” and “critique” the proposal. But without any of the data the consultants won’t supply, how can they do that?

ERS admitted during the meeting that they had never worked with a district in need of this level of restructuring. A consulting firm that can barely stomach the words “school closures” must speak directly and openly, and publicly share all the data they have. They must treat adults, especially parents, like the responsible, invested stakeholders they are.