Earlier this month, millions of families missed out on a bipartisan plan to improve the child tax credit — one of the most effective benefits in the federal tax code — while closing a major corporate tax loophole to pay for it. The fault lies with Senate Republicans, who refused to give Democrats a clear policy victory in the middle of a presidential election.

But if there’s a silver lining in this episode, it’s this: With the child tax credit back in the news, it should provide both presidential campaigns an opportunity to set aside schoolyard taunts and make improvements to this essential program central to their policy pitch to the American people. While there are differences in approach between Democrats and Republicans, there is broad agreement that the CTC is good for American families and the American economy.

Prioritizing lower-income families

The scuttled bill had been negotiated by Sen. Ron Wyden, D-Ore., and Rep. Jason Smith, R-Mo., and overwhelmingly passed the House. It would have corrected provisions in the current CTC that limit the benefits to lower-income families in two ways.

First, it would have ensured the “phase-in” portion of the CTC would take into account the number of children in a family. The “phase-in” refers to the way the CTC increases from zero to the full credit for families who make between $2,500 and about $15,000 per year. This provision is meant to encourage parents to work, but in its current form it punishes families with multiple children because the phase-in accumulates per family instead of per child. That means that the poorest families get only one child’s-worth of credit, no matter the size of their families.

Advertise with us

Second, it would have eventually eliminated the “refundability” gap in the CTC. Right now, only $1,600 of the $2,000 credit is considered “refundable,” which means families can receive it even if they owe less in taxes than they receive in credits. This unnecessarily punishes low-income families. Taken together, the two corrections would ensure low-income families receive benefits comparable to high-income families.

The progressive Center on Budget and Policy Priorities estimated that, all told, the Wyden-Smith bill would have increased benefits to 16 million children, and bring another half-million above the poverty line. The bill remained revenue-neutral by ending a fraud-plagued COVID-era business tax credit program.

Optimal CTC policy

While Senate Republicans couldn’t bring themselves to pass the bill in August of an election year, it could and should still be a starting point for presidential campaigns make proposals of their own. This is particularly important because the Trump tax cuts, which are set to expire in 2025, also included a doubling of the CTC from $1,000 to $2,000. Even if the rest of the cuts are allowed to expire, the boosted CTC must not be.

But both campaigns can also think bigger. For instance, millions of American families remember fondly the extremely generous CTC boost during the COVID pandemic, when the credit reached $3,600 per child under age 6, and $3,000 per older child. Even better, the IRS paid out the credit in monthly installments, bolstering monthly family budgets rather than forcing them to wait till tax season to reap the benefits.

A return to the 2021 CTC is imprudent: It further increased skyrocketing federal deficits while likely adding to inflationary pressures on the economy. However, there are lessons to be learned from it: The generous monthly payments pulled millions of children out of poverty, and reduced overall financial pressures not just on low-income families, but on middle-class families as well.

Advertise with us

Both presidential campaigns should consider a return to optional monthly CTC payments, as well as revenue-neutral ways to expand the credit beyond $2,000. There is no greater investment in the future of American society and the American economy than helping families provide for their children, and perhaps encouraging them to have one more.

Bipartisan appeal

Despite the polarization of American politics, exemplified by the ideological divergence between the presidential tickets and the tenor of the campaigns’ rhetoric, the child tax credit should be an area of convergence.

While the child tax credit generally doesn’t figure prominently in Donald Trump’s rhetoric, it is a staple of his running-mate’s approach to family policy. In this, Ohio Sen. JD Vance has positioned himself in the reform wing of the GOP, closer to young populists like Sen. Josh Hawley, Mo., than the more libertarian old guard represented by Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, Ky.

Meanwhile — despite contrary and false assertions by Mr. Vance — Vice President Kamala Harris has also been a long-time supporter of the child tax credit. Moreover, running-mate Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz signed into law one of the most generous state-level CTCs in the country: $1,750 per child for low-income parents that begins phasing out at $35,000 income for joint filers.

This is an area where both campaigns could produce thoughtful and competing policy proposals for enhancing support for American families. For instance, they might consider allowing the Trump tax cuts for the highest earners to lapse, and to use the savings to fund an expansion of the CTC for lower-income families.

It is probably fanciful to hope for this presidential election to be reoriented around brass-tacks policy proposals for the common good. But if it happens, there’s no better place to start than the child tax credit.