While Thursday’s historic prisoner swap among United States, five of its allies and Russia is a tremendous diplomatic achievement, and should be cause for national celebration, in Western Pennsylvania it can only be bittersweet. That’s because Oakmont resident Marc Fogel, who turned 63 on July 28, continues to languish in a Russian prison.
It’s now nearly three years since Mr. Fogel, a teacher with decades of experience educating children of American diplomats around the world, was detained at a Russian airport and accused of “trafficking” marijuana. He was said to be carrying about half-an-ounce — a non-trivial amount, but not enough to seriously traffic — of legal-in-America medical marijuana to treat serious back pain. In 2022, a Russian court imposed an absurd sentence of 14 years of hard labor, which would keep Mr. Fogel in prison and in pain until he is well into his 70s.
Now that journalists Evan Gershkovich of the Wall Street Journal, Alsu Kurmasheva of Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty and Vladimir Kara-Murz of the Washington Post, along with former U.S. Marine Paul Whelan, have been freed, the State Department must keep the pressure on Vladimir Putin’s regime to bring Mr. Fogel home. That begins with accurately designating the Oakmont teacher as “wrongly detained.”
’Wrongfully detained’
Amid the heartache for Mr. Fogel’s family and community this week, as it became clear that he was not among the released prisoners, there was a sliver of hopeful progress: For the first time, a U.S. official — National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan — referred to Mr. Fogel as “wrongfully detained.”
Still, this does not amount to a legal designation from the State Department. Under the Robert Levinson Hostage Recovery and Hostage-Taking Accountability Act, if an American arrested abroad fulfills certain criteria, the official “wrongfully detained” designation authorizes additional diplomatic efforts on behalf of the detained individual. Unaccountably, the State Department has not only resisted applying this designation to Mr. Fogel, but even to explain itself.
It is widely acknowledged that he does not fulfill the first criteria of innocence — he did have marijuana in his luggage — but the law considers innocence only one of several possible criteria. Others include being “detained solely or substantially because he or she is a United States national” or “to secure economic or political concessions from the United States Government”; “detained in a country where the Department of State has determined … that the judicial system is not independent or impartial”; and “detained in inhumane conditions.”
And then, lastly, the designation can be triggered if “United States diplomatic engagement is likely necessary to secure the release of the detained individual.” Marc Fogel fulfills all of these criteria, and should be designated “wrongfully detained” not just informally by the National Security Advisor, but officially by the State Department.
The Marc Fogel Act
Throughout Mr. Fogel’s ordeal, several Pennsylvania members of Congress have vocally supported him publicly and behind the scenes. Statements on Thursday’s prisoner swap by U.S. Reps. Chris Deluzio, D-Aspinwall; Summer Lee, D-Swissvale; Guy Reschenthaler, R-Peters; and Mike Kelly, R-Butler, along with U.S. Sen. Bob Casey, D, all expressed appropriately mixed emotions about the news, and offered their continued support to Mr. Fogel’s family.
Among these legislators, the work of Mr. Casey, Mr. Deluzio, whose district includes Oakmont, and Mr. Kelly, whose district included Mr. Fogel’s original home county of Butler, merit particular praise. Mr. Kelly has introduced the Marc Fogel Act, which would enhance transparency requirements for State Department “wrongfully detained” designations, so families and communities are not left in the dark about the bureaucratic processes that determine their loved ones’ fate. The bill has been co-sponsored by Mr. Deluzio and Mr. Reschenthaler, as well as Rep. Brendan Boyle, D-Philadelphia.
While the delicacy of diplomacy does require at least some secrecy, there’s no good reason to obscure the procedures the department uses to determine eligibility, especially from Congress. If any good comes from this tragedy, it would be enhanced transparency at the State Department — if Congress passes the Marc Fogel Act.
What we value most
This week’s prisoner swap, including 24 people and seven countries, was a historic feat of diplomacy for which the Biden administration should take full credit. The fact that the United States fought to free journalists while the Putin regime in Russia fought to free thugs and assassins says a great deal about what the two governments value most.
In a particular way, the liberation of Evan Gershkovich represents the enduring value of the free press to American society, and to the entire world. Russian authorities arrested Mr. Gershkovich on spurious espionage charges while he was doing his job: reporting on the state of Russian society. But that made him a target, who could be used as a bargaining chip.
Some may be uncomfortable with seemingly rewarding Russia’s behavior by engaging in good-faith negotiations, and returning Russian nationals who had been justly tried and convicted in Western courts. That is understandable. But it would also be wrong not to use the power at America’s disposal to mitigate the suffering of Americans who are being mistreated by rogue governments. Ultimately this requires a balancing of strategy and values: Here, the United States got it right.
But there is still more work to do. As long as Marc Fogel languishes in a Russian prison, justice still has not been completely served. The State Department must upgrade his status to “wrongfully detained” and redouble efforts to bring him home. Anything less would be un-American.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.