The City of Pittsburgh’s current and projected budgets continue to be propped up by dubious revenues and accounting tricks, all while Mayor Ed Gainey has gone on a hiring spree. The result is a financial Potemkin Village that obscures the city’s profound structural weaknesses — which will ultimately force a state oversight board to make the hard decisions the Gainey administration has been unwilling to make.

The gravity of the situation was underscored this week, when the Pennsylvania Supreme Court agreed to consider Pittsburgh’s appeal of multiple lower court decisions striking down the city’s Facilities Usage Fee, colloquially known as the “jock tax.” Despite the judicial rebukes, and the unlikelihood of prevailing at the high court, the Gainey administration has continued to collect the tax, artificially juicing city revenues while triggering heftier refunds once the tax is, in all likelihood, finally nixed.

It’s a perfect example of the administration’s decision-making, generating the illusion of stability in the immediate term while piling up liabilities in not-distant future. And it’s part of a pattern, from the jock tax to the parks tax.

Diverted parks tax

While no one questions the legal legitimacy of the Pittsburgh parks tax, which went into effect in January 2021, the way its proceeds have been used by the Gainey administration has spurned the will of voters, and confirmed the fears of the tax’s opponents. Specifically, rather than being used to transform the city’s most derelict recreational assets, much of the fund has been used to house salaries that should be part of the city’s general operating budget.

Advertise with us

In other words, the parks tax is being used in part as a supplement to the general fund, rather than what voters ratified: a dedicated parks fund.

Nearly half a million dollars in salaries that had been paid by the general fund are now paid by the parks fund, which frees up money to be used elsewhere without actually enhancing Pittsburgh’s parks. Further, the administration has deployed nearly $2 million from the parks tax fund as part of a massive expansion of the Department of Public Works’ corps of laborers.

When other wages that should be part of core city services, and not a dedicated parks improvement fund, are added in — administrative specialists, project managers, foremen — over $3 million, or more than a third of annual revenues, is being diverted from the parks fund to supplement the overall budget.

Meanwhile, there has been little visible improvement in the city’s parks. For every modest success story, such as the Anderson Playground in Schenley Park that was already in adequate condition before funds were plowed into it, there are several derelict facilities, such as the Manchester Spray Park, where promises have been continually deferred.

This is a clear violation of the will of the voters who supported the parks tax — and an example of how creative accounting is making the general fund look healthier than it is.

Advertise with us

Jock refunds

The jock tax is an even more direct version of propping up the city’s budget in a deceptive and unsustainable way.

The so-called “Facility Usage Fee” levies a 3% wage tax on out-of-town athletes and performers who use the city’s major venues. While such a tax is expressly permitted as part of a city’s emergence from Act 47 financial distress, it’s the amount of the tax that’s constitutionally problematic.

That’s because Pittsburgh levies a 1% earned income tax on residents, but 3% on nonresident athletes and performers, violating the “uniformity clause” in the state’s highest law. The city’s argument that the tax should be permissible because residents pay a total of 3% between city and school district earned income taxes has been rejected by both the Court of Common Pleas and the Commonwealth Court.

While it is possible that the state Supreme Court will reverse those decisions, that would be a major innovation in uniformity clause jurisprudence. And that’s no basis on which to balance a budget.

Not only is the jock tax included in — and essential to — the Gainey administration’s long-term budget projections, but the city has continued to collect it despite judicial rebukes. That will only increase the budget-busting refunds the city will owe.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh’s liability would likely depend on negotiations between the city and the athletes’ unions, and then on how many athletes actually apply for reimbursement. Cleveland ended up paying back about $2.5 million when its more limited jock tax was struck down; Pittsburgh would certainly owe much more.

Taxing suburbanites

City Office of Management and Budget Director Jake Pawlak has said that “we don’t have a structural challenge” but rather a “temporary fiscal challenge.” This is either deeply ignorant or deeply dishonest. Neither option is encouraging.

The only reason city government is not currently cutting staff and services is because the crisis is being papered over with dubious revenues like the jock tax, and dubious uses of funds like the parks tax. Needless to say the hiring of dozens of new laborers is only making the problem worse.

This all raises the question of what happens when Potemkin Pittsburgh collapses. There are two options: Either the mayor — whoever that may be — makes hard decisions about cutting expenditures and raising (real) revenues, or the state will once again impose itself on Pittsburgh.

This is where southwestern Pennsylvanians outside Pittsburgh should listen up: Within Act 47 financial distress, there is one revenue-raising option the city did not use last time. And that’s a commuter tax.

Advertise with us

If Pittsburgh can’t figure out its own problems, it will likely have to tax the wages of nonresidents who work in the city — including remote workers employed by Pittsburgh-based companies. Among other effects, this would further erode Pittsburgh’s reputation as a place in which to do business.

The stakes of Pitts­burgh’s fi­nan­cial mis­man­age­ment ex­tend well past the next few years, and well beyond city limits.