This building is too tall. This building is too expensive. This building is just right.

The problem for developers in Pittsburgh is that the just right Goldilocks zone, determined by a combination of zoning laws and the whims of various boards and commissions, leaves little to no room for financially viable projects that provide jobs, expand housing and generate economic activity in the city. The result is a development pipeline that is nearly empty, leaving Pittsburgh facing years of stagnation that will limit tax revenues just as a fiscal crisis looms.

Recent project cancelations and delays, headlined by the Community Supermarket site in Bloomfield and the Bakery Square expansion in Larimer and East Liberty, have made clear the need for comprehensive reform to the city’s zoning and development approval systems. As it stands, the system is premised on the idea that building in Pittsburgh is a unique privilege, and that developers must happily accept whatever hurdles they are asked to clear. But with current financing limitations and sharp competition from suburban markets and from other cities, that assumption no longer holds.

The zoning pincer

The most striking example of the Goldilocks problem in Pittsburgh development is the grocery store site where Liberty Ave, Main St and the Bloomfield Bridge meet. Echo Realty proposed to build a six-story, 248-unit development on the roughly 1.5-acre property, including a Giant Eagle supermarket, but abandoned the plan earlier this month.

Advertise with us

That’s because the Bloomfield site is within overlapping zoning areas whose constraints are, in practice, mutually exclusive for multi-family development. Its primary zone is “local neighborhood commercial,” which limits building heights to 45 feet (or three stories) in order to maintain continuity with existing main-street-style architecture. But it’s also in the “inclusionary zoning” overlay, which requires that developments of 20 or more units set aside at least 10% for households below 50% of the area median income.

Each affordable-by-fiat unit costs developers about $250,000 in their long-term financial calculations, which would add up to over $6 million for the Echo plan. In order to make up for such losses — and make the project tolerable for banks whose commercial real estate lending has tightened in recent years — the Bloomfield proposal needed to be taller than the three stories permitted by the zoning code. Echo’s attempt to seek a variance from the Zoning Board of Adjustment was rejected.

As a result of the zoning pincer, one of Pittsburgh’s most vibrant neighborhoods will have a large surface parking lot at its busiest intersection for several years to come. And 248 apartments that could have alleviated the city’s housing shortage — and contributed to overall lower rents — will not be built.

Too suburban? Or too urban?

About two miles down the busway, Walnut Capital continues to run into resistance to its $500 million, 800-unit, mixed-use expansion plans for Bakery Square. As the Post-Gazette Editorial Board previous reported, shenanigans in the Department of Planning held the project in stasis for several months. Eventually, Mayor Ed Gainey struck a deal with the developer that very modestly increased the share of affordable units — but now it appears that deal will be subsidized by taxpayer dollars.

The newest hurdle for Walnut Capital is the city’s Planning Commission, which has the nearly unchecked power to stymy development projects. At its July meeting, members of the commission objected to various aspects of the Bakery Square expansion plan in ways that were, once again, mutually contradictory.

Advertise with us

For instance, Commissioner Peter Quintanilla argued that the developer’s proposal that a maximum of 25% of parking would be surface parking (as opposed to structured parking) was evidence of “suburban-style thinking.” At the same meeting, senior planning manager Kate Rakus argued for more significant setbacks from the street to avoid a “canyon” sensation on Penn Avenue. Which raises the question: Are Walnut Capital’s plans too suburban, or too urban?

And just right may require so many delays and concessions that the project can’t be completed at all.

Threading the needle

Not every imposition on developers is bad. While the zoning code should be far less restrictive in general, limitations on what can be built where protect the investments of property owners by ensuring the neighborhood to which they’ve committed themselves does not change too radically. And Mr. Quintanilla, from the Planning Commission, is not wrong to insist on minimal surface parking for a properly urban development — though his counterproposal of street parking only goes too far, ignoring the need for amenities like loading and drop-off zones.

Altogether, however, Pittsburgh’s zoning and development system represents the accretion of layer upon layer of restrictions and bureaucracy. This has steadily shrunk the size of the needle developers must thread, while increasing the amount of time — in a deeply uncertain financial environment — it takes to get projects across the finish line.

This is one reason why adding further restrictions, like citywide “inclusionary zoning,” must be avoided. It will expand across the city the pincer that killed the Community Supermarket development, and shrink the Goldilocks zone down to nearly nothing, from Sheraden to Regent Square, from Overbrook to Brighton Heights.

Advertise with us

But the situation demands active reform, not just avoiding making it worse. That means liberating development — including especially small-scale development, like duplexes and small apartment buildings — by reducing the number of zoning types, and loosening the restrictions they impose. It also means rethinking the bureaucracy of development, including reducing wait times and the number of people and boards who must be appeased before a development can proceed.

Pittsburgh’s economic and demographic stagnation is not inevitable: It is, at least in part, a policy choice. But by reducing restrictions, and thereby expanding the Goldilocks zone, the city can liberate the builders who want to grow Pittsburgh.

Correction: This editorial has been updated to reflect a more accurate description of the surface parking proposed by Walnut Capital for the Bakery Square expansion project.