This year’s Republican National Convention, culminating this evening with an address by former president Donald Trump, is likely to be remembered as a seminal moment in American political history. Whether it is remembered as a turn toward deeper divisions and political despair, or as a turn toward a renewal of American optimism and political concord, will depend on the tone and substance of Mr. Trump’s speech.
It must be said at the outset that nothing Mr. Trump says on the RNC stage — besides an unreserved apology, which is beyond hope — can make up for, or place beyond memory, his atrocious conduct on Jan. 6, 2021, or his other offenses in word and action that have contributed to this era of disunion and distrust. He cannot wipe the slate clean.
But in the wake of the first attempted presidential assassination in 43 years, which came within inches of ending Mr. Trump’s life, and plunging America into a political catastrophe, it is not beyond hope that he might enter a new phase of his political life, marked by gratitude and optimism, and at least an attempt at offering grace to those who oppose him.
Donald Trump is, above all, a showman — and in particular a connoisseur of (and some-time participant in) professional wrestling. He knows the entertainment value of the “heel turn,” when a protagonist wrestler suddenly becomes an antagonist. But he should also know the great value of the “face turn,” when a character known for malevolence suddenly becomes the hero of the drama.
Thursday night in Milwaukee can be Mr. Trump’s face turn — if he wants it to be. The nation needs it to be.
A party transformed
Whatever Mr. Trump says in his address, it’s clear that this convention is consummating the transformation of the Republican Party from the party of Reagan to the party of Trump. Speakers have included Amber Rose, author of “How to be a Bad Bitch” and co-founder of a Los Angeles event called SlutWalk, and Sean O’Brien, president of the International Brotherhood of Teamsters. Opposition to abortion and same-sex marriage have been wiped off the party’s platform.
But nowhere is this transformation clearer than in the selection of Ohio Sen. JD Vance as Mr. Trump’s vice-presidential nominee. Mr. Vance is among the most strident supporters in Congress of Mr. Trump’s populism and nationalism. On issues from America’s relationship with Ukraine to the role of government in reining in corporate power, he represents a sharp break with the Reagan consensus of interventionism and limited government.
He also represents a complication for any turn toward a message of American unity. After Saturday’s assassination attempt, Mr. Vance was among the first elected officials to directly blame President Joe Biden — and, by extension, his supporters — for the assault. These are the kind of recriminations that will further drive Americans apart and, as the Editorial Board wrote in its response to the shooting, do the would-be assassin’s work of violence against America for him.
The need to turn
Still, it is possible for the Trump movement to become more magnanimous and hopeful, if Mr. Trump allows it to. In fact, it must, for the nation’s good: A movement based primarily on grievance cannot survive, because it eventually devours itself, and in the process devours others. It must turn its attention toward a better future for all Americans.
Many people believe, not without reason, that this is impossible. That the addiction to grievance is too strong to be broken. That Mr. Trump himself, and any political movement inspired by him, can never manifest the kind of graciousness necessary to rebuild the bridges of social togetherness than have been burned.
Those people may be right. But if they are right — or if they are unwilling to concede the possibility they may be wrong — then America will be unable to come together, perhaps ever again.
The truth is that with this Republican National Convention, there can no longer be any doubt that the Trump movement and the Republican Party are one and the same, and will be for some time to come. This means that for the foreseeable future, about half of Americans — give or take a few percentage points based on the election cycle — will support the Trump movement.
Extirpating that movement through democratic means is not possible; doing so beyond democratic means is the end of the American experiment. The Trump movement is an inescapable fact of American political life. The question is what is to be done about that fact.
The most important speech
The Trump movement, and the man at its head, must turn to hope and to graciousness. This doesn’t mean capitulating on its main points of policy and ideology, about which there can and should be vigorous democratic debate. It does mean accepting the legitimacy of fair elections, and the necessity of coexistence (and shared thriving!) with fellow Americans who aren’t going anywhere, any more than Trump supporters are going anywhere.
In turn, Mr. Trump’s opponents must be open to the possibility that they can live with him and his supporters, even if he wins the White House.
Thursday night’s speech, coming in the wake of a moment that was inches away from precipitating the country’s worst political crisis since the Civil War, is Mr. Trump’s best opportunity to make this turn to magnanimity and hope. It will be be the most important speech of his life. It may be the most important speech in recent American history.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.